If the 50W Is As Good As The 30W, Stand aside, Innokin (by aldenf)



http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/variable-voltage-apv-discussion/637976-eleaf-istick-50w-coming-jan-25th-12.html#post15039009



aldenf;15039009 said:
For $50, if iSmoka builds the 50W like my 30W, it will clean up...

For those looking for complete empirical test results, they'll be a while. The 30W is performing so well for me that any further testing is purely academic. I will post scope traces at the end. I did an unboxing post on the main istick thread, if anyone's interested.

Let's start at the top.

The 510 connection is much improved. Threading is clean and stainless steel. The center pin is spring-loaded with what appears to be a 3mm travel.

I have topped it with:

510-eGo adapter and EVODv1 & EVOD Glass with 1.6Ω/1.8Ω stock heads and 1.4Ω rebuilds.
ProTank2 w/AFC with rebuilt Kanger heads, both 1.8Ω horizontal and 1.6Ω BVC
AnyVape Peakomizer with 1.6Ω rebuilt Kanger BVC
Erlkonigin Clone with 1.7Ω 28g/rayon
KayfunLite+ v2 with 1.6Ω twisted 30g/rayon
IGO L with 0.8Ω twisted 28g/rayon
Plume Veil Clone with 0.5Ω dual twisted 30g/rayon
Veritas Clone with 0.8Ω single twisted 28g/rayon

All atomizers:

Sit flush and solid with the top cap.
Have solid, consistent resistance.
Fire every time I push the button.


Below the top cap, the 30W appears to be physically identical to the 20W.
- I can hold it and use it in the exact same manner.
- Buttons still rattle. But everything else is solid.
- The brilliant form-factor and weight are the same.

I haven't taken it apart yet. So I can't speak to workmanship and quality control.
- Rest assured that I will be reinforcing the USB with some epoxy or hot glue just as I did my second 20W.


The chipset appears to be doing its job, reasonably close to spec.

Resistance readings are spot on, maybe < 0.1Ω high.
5-30W
2-8V
It fires directly out of sleep and every time I press the button. (ie. no phantom button issues)
PWM, 22kHz with light "filtering", tuned to RMS
Every atomizer I put on it fires beautifully with no burning. This is a pretty smooth vape, folks.
It may be firing a bit hot, <25%. But even a minimum of 2.5V will allow us to fire practically anything we have at our preferred vape.
- Even twists/spinners only fire down to 3.2V minimum. Some are higher.
Settings lock works as speced.
Lefty/Righty mode is there.
Still no stealth mode.
The battery still wears those bunny ears.


I could sit here and nit-pick. But I don't expect the 30W iStick to regulate as well as a ProVari, have the build quality of a ZEN Mod or the beauty of many hand-crafted, bespoke mods. If we expect any of the aforementioned, we should be prepared to dig deeper into our pockets.

In summary, if you like the 20W iStick, you will love the 30watter. It is everything the 20W SHOULD have been with more power, across a wider range of resistances. For $35, the iStick 30W is a no-brainer.


We do know that the iStick is firing in PWM, at 22kHz. That's pretty fast folks; MUCH faster than a ProVari. This allows Eleaf to apply some light "filtering". (Higher frequencies are easier and cheaper to filter.) Don't expect ProVari level filtering however. The signal is much dirtier than a ProVari but MUCH smoother than the original iStick. It's output is tuned to RMS!

The original iStick's regulation was pretty darned good but tuned to Vavg. The 30W does not seem to regulate as tightly and seems to fire slightly hot. In the example below, firing at 3V, the 30W iStick is actually firing 3.38V. That is an unloaded measurement. So full testing is required to determine complete regulation capabilities.

500ms trace



Zoomed in to 1ms.




iStick 30W with some of its new family.




Good luck, everyone!

I hate typing one-handed. :vapor:

Comments

There are no comments to display.

Blog entry information

Author
Katdarling
Views
3,074
Last update

More entries in ECF Blogs

More entries from Katdarling