This article, recently published in the
Harm Reduction Journal is definitely worth reading.
http://www.harmreductionjournal.com/content/pdf/1477-7517-8-19.pdf
Those of you who are new to this arena may not realize that e-cigarettes are just one tool that can be used to reduce the harm caused by smoking. Any non-combusted form of nicotine is less hazardous than inhaling smoke. Options would include e-cigarettes, snus, dissolvable
tobacco products (orbs, strips, sticks) and even NRTs used long term. The concept is known as
tobacco Harm Reduction (THR) and it is
not warmly embraced by those working in tobacco control. They want us to have two choices:
A - Abstinence only, from all tobacco products.
C - Continue smoking -- kill yourself, see if we care.
They don't want us to have option
B - Better tobacco products
We call this the "Quit or Die" mentality.
Dr. Brad Rodu of the University of Louisville looks at where the science has led between 2006 and 2011. The folks who don't want you to have Option B are pretty much ignoring the science, even though they have "MD" and/or "PhD" or even "MPH" behind their names. Sometimes they make up their own science and get it published by their buddies running such medical journals as Tobacco Control, JAMA, and NEJM. And unfortunately, these are the folks driving the bus at the moment.