The Plume Room is a new shop that uses natural flavorings and their own tobacco extracts. Definitely worth a try, especially if you're interested in tobacco flavors. Only a handful to choose from (more are in the works), but they're all complex and thoughtfully crafted. What I sampled was a little sweet for my personal preference, but I still highly recommend this vendor. Andrea, the woman who makes everything, clearly cares about what she's doing. She's also super nice and sent me a personal follow up email, and threw in an extra 5ml bottle to sample because it took her an extra day to process my order. Plus all liquids come in blue glass bottles with plastic pipettes. Shipping is priority flat rate/$5.
Burley + Candy
Hard to describe, but after steeping for a week or two I think it's the best one of the lot. A fruity/sugary taste on inhale, which lingers on exhale but there's also somehow an entirely new flavor too, sort of a warm tobacco/bakery thing that reminds me of NLV Gold from nitelitevapor. I'd definitely include this one if you place an order.
Arctic Cowboy (tobacco/vanilla/mint)
The vanilla and mint are really subtle. This one uses tobacco flavoring instead of extracted, but whatever it is I haven't tasted anything similar yet, so I can't think of what to compare it to. The tobacco part has a fresh but not too sharp taste and an herbal/cut grass kind of thing going on. I'm not sure it'd be for everyone, but I liked it. Also was the only one without much (if any) sweetener.
Honey Fig Tobacco
Another home-brew. Fruity tobacco flavor that reminds me of the way tobacco shops smell, or I guess of opening a jar of pipe tobacco. No smokey taste, just warm, aromatic, and sweet. Nice over all, except for a faint perfume-like note.
Vanilla Caramel Frappuccino
Really good! I'd never drink an actual vanilla caramel frappucino but it works here. All the flavors are there and come together really well. Liked it even better than the kona milkshake flavor from virgin vapors (although that's also really good).