Tobacco Flavor Reviews from a n00b

[bluesuede]

From Wet Your Stick: Best tobacco flavor -ever- I have found is Cuban Cigar. Not sweet at all. Very, very good. Tobacco is also good, milder. These two probably comes closest to an analog IMHO.

What surprised me was Vanilla. I tried a sample bottle. I don't like sweet stuff but this was good and not sweet at all, just a subtle vanilla flavor. Mixing Vanilla with Cuban Cigar or Tobacco is also wonderful. I'll be ordering a 30 ml bottle of Vanilla next order.

[uzzaperez]

On bluesude's advice I tried the Cuban Cigar flavor, the biggest hole in my original post. Cuban Cigar absolutely comes closer to an analog than any other flavor I've tried. Keeping with my original scale (see first post, this thread) I give it 5 thumbs up and rank it at the top of the tobacco flavors right up there with the sweet-molasses-y Virginia flavor.

If you are looking for that analog tobacco flavor, Cuban seems to be the thing for sure.

Funny thing - after trying a bunch of flavors in 5ml size, and then trying to use up the ones I didn't really like, I kept actually not looking forward to vaping the flavors I didn't prefer - I just kept wanting to go back to the flavors I actually liked. But, not wanting to just waste all that juice I finally decided to blend about 35ml of Marlboro (my old stock that didn't measure up with Virginia and Cuban) with the 5ml each of other flavors I liked in varying degrees but didn't prefer; Camel, Hilton, French Pipe, Mint, and Peach. Sure the last two aren't tobacco flavors, but they aren't sufficient flavors to stand alone so they went in the mix. Maybe it was just luck but I came out with about 60ml of a decent mild and mildly tastey tobacco flavor that I'd rank at about 3.5 thumbs. Not bad. Maybe I wouldn't recommend random mixing but it saved about 60ml of juice I was pretty much ready to toss out.