I thought that no liquid smelled until I was vaping RY4 in the office (secretly) and when the next person came in they said "It smells like cotton candy in here". I just said "really? I don't smell anything". So I thought hmm ok maybe it was something else....until it happened again with a different person. So yeah Riskee Juice does have a smell. No one has ever made a comment on my menthol yet.