Here are my contributions to this awesome thread. The analogs I smoked were Camel Jade/Crush/Silver, so I'm a big fan of the peppermint flavors. My reviews will be biased towards the mint flavors, which is truly what has helped me quit analogs. All of my reviews are based on 18mg nicotine, 50/50 PG/VG and on the Joye 510 e-cig.
Stuff I like
1) Wintergreen: This is my #1 go-to vape because of it's strong, mint flavor. This one reminds me enough of Camel Crush to stave off any analog cravings that I have.
2) Cool Fusion: I absolutely love this flavor - it's lightly peachy with a good mint undertone. Very refreshing and great as an all-day vape.
3) Peppermint Cream: This flavor is a more muted mint flavor with a nice creamy undertone to balance everything out.
Stuff I don't like
4) Spearmint: Unfortunately this one tastes far too much like gum for me to truly enjoy it. It''s quite strong in flavor, so if you're into Trident, this is probably for you.
5) Irish Cream: I love Irish Cream normally, but I simply don't enjoy this one. I have a tough time pinpointing why, but it's not for me.
6) Chocolate Cake, Chocolate Strawberry, & Peppermint Patty: For some reason, I just can't get into the chocolate flavors. They all seem very thick and cocoa-y to me, not at all like chocolate really tastes in the mouth.
Edited to fix run-on sentence.