I am a big menthol fan. I have been pleased with nhaler's nuport. The peppery taste, that I suppose is there to mimic smoke, gets a little old. It is also a bit on the pricey side. I have avoided NET liquids because I don't care for the pipe
tobacco taste. That being said, I just purchased some Dark Horse from HHV because I heard it isn't as upfront with the pipe tobacco flavor profile. I am anxious to see if it plays well with menthol. I smoked full flavor Kools for many a year, and while I really don't crave that burning tobacco taste, I must have the menthol kick.