I would venture to guess that since most folks arent self confirmed atheists, when they enter these 12 step programs, they can be "indoctrinated" into the belief that acceptance of god is the only way. NOW... I am all for getting clean if your willing to do so. I am in no position to tell these folks that they shouldnt take the help because its theistically based. If it works... do it.
I had this argument in another
thread, with someone who said that in their state if you are convicted of a DWI, you are forced to enter a 12 step program which includes the help of god, or face jail. I was utterly disgusted that a state would MANDATE such a choice. Jail, or religious addiction therapy? Really? He stuck to his guns and said that was the rule. Its blackmail of the highest order imo, and almost makes me want to go get a DWI in his state just so I can sue the state for imposing religion on me or go to jail... that was done during the inquisitions. I see no need to repeat in the 2011.
Theists know all to well that the best time to gain converts is at a time in a persons life when their luck is down, or their morality is in dispare. Being an admitted (or caught) alcoholic is one such moment. And addicts who are willing to try to recover are often times willing to "do whatever it takes"... incuding accepting religious myths. Having never been an alcoholic, and never joining a 12 step program, Im uneducated as to the degree to which they promote a deity. I have one family member who did though. By his reports, the religious underpinnings werent too bad... but they were there. He also comes from a catholic family, so talk of god wasnt all that offensive to him.
I can say with confidence that if I became an addict searching for help, AA wouldnt be my choice. I would most likely search out a program
through the local UU Church or even join one of their recovery programs. Non religious programs exist. We dont hear about them because AA is such a houshold name in recovery that it over shadows most others.
A simple online search for "non religious addiction recovery programs" yeilded these hits:
Ratiomal and Secular Programs : The Addiction Recovery Guide
Non-Religious Rehab - Secular or Non-Religious Alcohol Drug Rehab Programs
SoberRecovery : Non 12 step - Drug and Alcohol Treatment Centers
Heres a story about the very issue I discussed above... mandating AA in lew of jail time. This fellow is already incarcerated but is refusing to participate in the jail recovery program. In brief, he says he is within his rights to decline the program because:
"Courts around the country, however, have ruled the 12-step program of Alcoholics Anonymous is religious. In June of 1996, the New York Court of Appeals ruled that the New York Department of Corrections substance abuse program was unconstitutional because, "after a fair reading of the doctrinal literature of Alcoholics Anonymous (the 12-step program was found to be) unequivocally religious."
Prisoner wants non-religious alternative to AA
That is good info if your an atheist addict seeking alternative treatement. Anyway... to continue:
SMART Recovery® | Self Help for Alcoholism & Addiction
drug - alcohol - addiction - SOS-Save Our Selves - Non 12 Step
And for those who demand that religious programs are the only way to recover, I would suggest directing
them to these sites:
Recovering Fundamentalists Recovery Program | Find help recovering from abusive religion.
Recovery from Religion Meetups near Concord, California - Recovery from Religion Meetups - Concord
Recovery from Religion Meetup Groups - Recovery from Religion Meetups
Recovery from Religion | MarleneWinell.net
You're not a sheep, you dont need to follow the herd.
-VP