Sweet Quick Nic review!! Enigma is one of my favs, you should try it again, it seems different flavors come out later! To me it's more chocolate and caramel with some vanilla, and something else too, maybe a cream, maybe a marshmallow...sometimes that vanilla comes out more than other times. Everyone seems to describe it a little differently, that's why its called Enigma! Btw have you ever tried Johnson Creek's Solstice? It is watermelon, honeydew & mint and also a fav of mine....I'm not sure if I told you about it when you were looking for watermelon...its not straight watermelon but its SO good (in my opinion). Also if you haven't check out PBdragon's watermelon flavor! Great ending of the vid too LOL nice hat!