1/29/14 - CASAA STOPS La Mesa Ban; ECFZone on mnors; Dr. Siegal on NEJM study; IA heats up - EU, UK, US: NY; PA; WV; OH; KY; MI; ND; WI; IA; OK; CA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jan 19, 2014
1,039
2,370
Moved On
As many of you already know: proposed La Mesa CA *total vaping sales ban* stopped by CASAA; ECFInfoZone takes on the minors argument; Dr. Siegal on the recent NJEM study - conflicts of interest; C.V. Phillips on NYT writer Jane Brody; action heats up in IA

Coverage EU; UK; US States: NY; PA; WV; OH; KY; MI; ND; WI; IA; OK; CA [all links not coming from this site; CASAA; Dr. Siegal; C.V. Phillips, etc. are broken]

***

(Our own ECFZone) Minors, Money, and Misinformation - ECF InfoZone [Gary Cox takes on the issue of sales to minors, and how it's being used as a wedge for taxation, etc.]

***

(Dr. Siegal's blog) http://tobaccoanalysis.blogspot.com/2014/01/nejm-editorial-written-by-anti-tobacco.html [on conflicts of interest in the recent NEJM study; for C.V. Phillips' take: _http://antithrlies.com/2014/01/23/nejm-insight/ )

***

(C.V. Phillips' blog) Jane Brody turns up the NYT’s lies about THR, e-cigarettes, etc. | Anti-THR Lies and related topics [discusses NYT writer Jane Brody's hit jobs on vaping]

***

(Vaper's 'Zine - EU Law) Health Scientists Criticize European Union's New E-Cigarette Law | E-Cigarette Reviews and Rankings (more on the letter criticizing EU anti-vaping policies; no junk]

***

(Gaurdian London UK) www . theguardian . com/sustainable-business/e-cigarettes-smokers-quit-glamorise-smoking [gen'l pros-vs.-cons of vaping; some junk but not totally unbalanced - 1.2M vapers in UK now out of 60M making UK perhaps the most vaper-dense country]

***

(Lincoln Park Patch - nat'l for-profit blog site) What Democrats Need to Know about E-Cigarettes and the Recent NYC and Chicago Bans on Usage - Victorian Chick on the Patch - Lincoln Park, IL Patch [excellent pro-vaping blog written by noted HuffPo blogger Victoria Ordin]

("campaign for tobacco-free kids" - US Nat'l) www . tobaccofreekids . org/press_releases/post/2014_01_15_chicago (press release applauding Chicago city council, chock-full of junk)

(NJ US GASP - ANTZ org) www . njgasp . org/E-Cigs_White_Paper.pdf [posted because this is by far the most accurate and consistently-updated list of vaping restrictions that I've found, just FYI]

***

(Weill Cornell Medical College NYC) copdsupport . wordpress . com/2014/01/28/seeking-volunteers-for-an-e-cigarette-research-study/ [seeking volunteers for vaping study; not clear whether this is a "hit job" study]

***

(Wash. Sq. News - ind. NYU-based paper NYC) nyunews . com/2014/01/29/e-cigarettes/ [NYU student/staff reactions to the NYC ordinance which treats vaping like tobacco burning; no junk]

***

(Point Park U., Pittsburgh PA US) www . pointparknewsservice . com/2014/01/28/e-cigarettes-renew-indoor-smoking-debate/ [Poorly-researched general article on indoor vaping with some junk]

***

(OH US Columbus Dispatch local paper) dispatchpolitics . dispatch . com/content/blogs/the-daily-briefing/2014/01/1-28-14-e-cig-debate.html [Report on Lorillard's bill to ban minor sales; ACA and other orgs call for taxation to boot - OH has no present restrictions I believe, so watch for the "minor morph" in OH]

(Upper Arlington OH US local paper) www . thisweeknews . com/content/stories/upperarlington/news/2014/01/28/city-may-ban-sale-of-e-cigarettes-to-minors.html [city council considers ban on minor sales; some junk; possible "minor morph"]

***

(Clarksburg WV US ind. radio station) www . wboy . com/story/24565980/e-cigarettes-becoming-more-popular-with-teenagers [junk-filled story about minors with some curious science - nicotine absorbed through the cheek (?)]

***

(Louisville KY US Courier Journal Local Paper) www . courier-journal . com/article/20140128/NEWS0101/301280085/E-cigarette-sales-minors-would-banned-under-Kentucky-bill [Some junk; covers minor sales ban bill introduced in KY; CASAA has issued an alert for KY tax bill: CASAA: Call to Action! Kentucky Bills to Ban E-Cigarette Usage & Impose 40% Tax ;KY indoor clean air act already bans inside vaping in public places]

(Shelby Co KY US local paper) www . sentinelnews . com/content/montell-files-bill-ban-e-cigarette-minors [similar to above]

***

(MLive Media owns local papers in MI US - about Genessee Co.) www . mlive . com/news/flint/index.ssf/2014/01/genesee_county_health_officer_1.html [Co. health officer repeats junk about targing of minors. Plenty of other junk there to support more than a ban on the sale to minors. Statewide bill pending, no other restrictions to my knowledge]

***

(Bismark ND US Tribune local paper) bismarcktribune . com/news/local/govt-and-politics/public-hearing-scheduled-on-proposed-e-cigarette-ban/article_c777742a-8882-11e3-b9e4-0019bb2963f4 . html [City council to hear ban on minors; ND already has ext'd clean air act to cover vaping. No junk just straight reporting.]

***

(Green Bay WI US local paper) www . greenbaypressgazette . com/article/20140128/GPG0602/301280371/Editorial-Schools-need-alter-policies-address-e-cigarette-use [Editorial urges local schools to treat vaping like tobacco burning; the usual junk.]

***

(C.V. Phillips' blog on IA Health Authorities) This is what local public health looks like, Iowa edition | Anti-THR Lies and related topics [oops I missed this one yesterday; Iowans pls. have a look]

(Des Moines IA US Register local paper) www . desmoinesregister . com/article/20140129/OPINION01/301290032/?odyssey=nav|head [Pro-vaping opinion piece, zero junk as far as I can tell. IA A/G would like to extend clean air act to cover vaping.]

(Des Moines IA ABC TV/Radio Affiliate) www . kcrg . com/news/local/Iowa-Lawmakers-Attempt-to-Ban-E-Cigarettes-for-Minors-Not-Enough-for-Public-Health-Advocates-242494901.html [More IA legislative bill discussion; watch for the "minor morph" in IA]

(Des Moines IA CBS TV/Radio Affiliate) www . kcci . com/news/central-iowa/both-house-senate-working-on-ecigarette-bans-for-minors/-/9357080/24162108/-/y31cdbz/-/index.html [gen'l report on minor bans in IA; no junk]

(IA City IA US local paper) www . press-citizen . com/article/20140128/NEWS01/140128012/Ban-e-cigarettes-minors-advances-Iowa-Legislature-not-everyone-approves [another report on minor bans in IA legis; state and other local health officials want vaping to be treated exactly like tobacco burning for purposes of clean air act, and taxes, etc.; some junk]

(Sioux City IA US local paper) siouxcityjournal . com/news/local/govt-and-politics/iowa-lawmakers-consider-banning-e-cigarettes-for-minors/article_9ce91b02-f166-5f0f-b5c2-bb2aecad7136 . html [similar to above]

(Radio IA US - owns many IA stations) www . radioiowa . com/2014/01/28/controversy-over-bill-to-ban-sale-of-e-cigarettes-to-minors/ [similar to above]

***

(OK City Fox Radio Station) www . okcfox . com/story/23532124/what-consumers-should-know-about-e-cigarette-explosions [charger fires story; doesn't appear to have junk and doesn't mention pending OK legis.]

***

(SF CA US CBS Affiliate - Richmond) sanfrancisco . cbslocal . com/video/9600571-richmond-votes-in-tough-ban-on-e-cigarettes/ [City of Richmond CA adds vaping to its smoke-free law which covers outdoor smoking as well on all city streets and sidewalks if anyone is nearby; I believe Richmond was one of a few municipalities that tried to ban all tobacco smoking except w/i free-standing owner-occupied private homes a few years ago; some junk]

(Orange Co. CA US Register) www . ocregister . com/articles/cigarettes-599180-smoking-ordinance.html [City of Seal Beach lifts the 5-month moratorium on new B&M licenses; treats vaping sales the same as analogs.]

(San Diego CA US Reader - La Mesa Ban tabled) www . sandiegoreader . com/news/2014/jan/29/ticker-la-mesa-considers-ban-e-cigarette-sales/ [CASAA Legis. Dir. Julie Woessner & other CASAA members *stop* blanket ban on sales of PVDs etc. proposed by Mayor. Good job! Some junk in citations from Mayor; he still wants to ban indoor vaping but all resolutions tabled.]

(San Diego CA US Union Tribune local paper on La Mesa Ban www . utsandiego . com/news/2014/jan/28/e-cigarettes-lively-discussion-la-mesa/ [same as above; some junk, also discussion of neighboring municipalities]

(Santa Barbara CA US - UCSB student paper) thebottomline . as . ucsb.edu/2014/01/to-vape-or-not-to-vape-inside-the-e-cigarette-revolution [generic article on popularity of vaping w/ UCSB students; very little junk; UC system bans vaping on campus except in designated tobacco burning areas - if indeed they have any]
 
Jan 19, 2014
1,039
2,370
Moved On

Don Robertson

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 28, 2013
537
837
Rio Rancho, New Mexico
Last edited:
Jan 19, 2014
1,039
2,370
Moved On
...
Looks like CASSA didn't get much press on this one. Can you site where they take credit? I see nothing on their web site.

They didn't take credit, but the media gave it to them, as you'll see in my the thread-starting post above:
(San Diego CA US Reader - La Mesa Ban tabled) www . sandiegoreader . com/news/2014/jan/29/ticker-la-mesa-considers-ban-e-cigarette-sales/ [CASAA Legis. Dir. Julie Woessner & other CASAA members *stop* blanket ban on sales of PVDs etc. proposed by Mayor. Good job! Some junk in citations from Mayor; he still wants to ban indoor vaping but all resolutions tabled.]

***

What the article actually says is:

As evidence of the need to eradicate the devices, [Mayor] Madrid included a copy of an opinion piece published in U-T San Diego last December. Also, Madrid presented a screen capture of a spam email he received offering a free e-cigarette sample in his note on the city-council meeting agenda (material pertinent to the proposed ban starts on page 105).

Not so fast, said CASAA (Consumer Advocates for Smoke-free Alternatives Association), a pro-e-cigarette activist group that launched a campaign Monday morning calling for local members to contact Madrid and council members and to attend the meeting in protest.

"They talk about the increased popularity of e-cigarettes as if it's a bad thing," said Julie Woessner, the group's legislative director. She and other advocates point to a peer-reviewed Drexel University study released this month that finds that the "current state of knowledge about chemistry of liquids and aerosols associated with electronic cigarettes indicates that there is no evidence that vaping produces inhalable exposures to contaminants of the aerosol that would warrant health concerns by the standards that are used to ensure safety of workplaces...exposures of bystanders are likely to be orders of magnitude less, and thus pose no apparent concern."

"When you hear stories about people who've made the complete transition [to using e-cigarettes], it's very powerful, and that's why we want to be a part of the conversation about regulation," Woessner said. "We don't believe e-cigarettes are a problem; we believe they're part of a solution."

That's about as much credit as you're going to get from the Media in a 6-paragraph story. CASAA was obviously there, and most of the article concerns their involvement.

***

...Folks should be concerned with the nut case legislation to ban shipment of e-cigarettes within California!

Yes, and they most certainly are: Legal status of electronic cigarettes in the USA - Map - ECF InfoZone

Also go to the Legislation News and check out: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...-shipment-e-cigarettes-anyone-california.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread