5V Regulator or DC Booster: Which is better?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dave Rickey

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 30, 2009
191
3
Austin TX
The answer to your question depends.... If the size and number of batteries is fixed, a switching buck regulator will be more efficient than the booster, which will be more efficient than a linear buck. On the other hand, if you're choosing between 2 small batteries vs. 1 large one (2 CR2's or CR123's vs. a single 18650, for example), the higher effective energy density of a larger cell moves things well in favor of the booster. The only advantage of a linear buck and two small cells is simplicity, you don't need as complicated a circuit or casing design.

I'm not sure what you mean about series or parallel? Do you mean parallel Li-Ions vs. series NiMH? That's mostly a matter of how you connect the contacts in the battery case.

The datasheet for the 4050C gives the info on how to set output to a voltage other than 5V, although in many cases the 12W power limit will kick in (510's at 6V, for example), and it also seems to move the capacitors from optional to mandatory.

--Dave
 

Guitarslinger

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 3, 2009
76
0
Central Illinois
Disregard that last post, lol-did a bit of searching, they are indeed adjustable to 15 v-but if you do nothing it reverts to the minimum output which is 5 v (4.98 with my tester anyway :)) So-got lucky there. Btw here is a link for the booster stats and wiring diagram if it helps anyone:

http://focus.ti.com/lit/ds/slts251/slts251.pdf

Sorry Dave-must've been typing same time you were so didn't see your post. Thanks for the info nonetheless. My plan was initially to use the booster on an 18650-so np there. The logic does make total sense afa single vs multiple batts also. Was probably gonna upgrade my 3 AA battery (14500) box in some fashion, not sure what yet. Thanks again
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread