Are our factory-made coils being wrapped too tightly?

Status
Not open for further replies.

GoodNews!

Moved On
Oct 25, 2013
577
136
Vaping, USA
Hey guys, I've been experimenting with the Smokin' Crow Hemp Wicked Clearomizer from Mountain Vapors, and while the big news is that without a doubt, I love hemp over silica (the dry hits are so extraordinarily tolerable compared to silica, and hemp really seems to recover the taste if it does burn a little), but the big, big problem is still this - even with hemp, I'm getting so many dry hits it's ridiculous, even my absolute thinnest juice is not performing anywhere near optimally (though it proves to wick better than the rest).

Now, with inspecting the coils that are re-built (I say this because the heads seem to be literally rebuilt - Smokin Crow seems manufacturer them with regular silica wicks, and the owner of Mountain Vapors seems to rebuild them), and I'm seeing a lot of issues that to me, appear to be the same issues with any other heads that are generally inspectable. For these heads (and virtually any other CE5 head), to me, the coils simply seem wrapped too tightly, combined with metal slots in the head that may not be big enough for juice to properly soak into the center of the wick, combined with this "heat guard" white material that I see no use for other than possibly making the vapor taste nasty (the coils are usually so far away from the metal that I don't see how the heat from them would really do anything other than making the tank a little warm...)

With doing some tests, such as dripping juice onto the wicks coming out of the head (using a dry head) and seeing how long it takes to flow into the center, it always seems to take forever with these types of heads, and even when it gets good and soaked, the moisture level of the wick underneath the coil always seems moist at best - it's never a gooped up, almost-dripping fluid fest that I see with a lot of rebuildables. While the slots in the metal head may pose an issue when the tank is assembled, I'm doing this test with the rubber cap off, and these particular heads having fully cut out slots when the rubber cap is off, so that isn't the issue initially. The next guess is that the white heat material, which seems to really present even "another" handicap for juice to flow to the center wick, may be slowing down juice flow.

However, the biggest thing I see is simply that the coils appear way too tight. These particular heads have like 7 individual strands concerning the wick, and yet those 7 strands (each bigger than diameter of "thread") are crowded into the coil and compressed all together to form a thickness of a piece of "yarn". How the juice really even wicks into this well is beyond me. Secondly, it looks as though the coil is tightly compressing these wicks - it looks as though the wicks themselves were used as a base to wrap the coil, rather than the coil being wrapped say with a crochet needle/coffee straw/toothpick/something and the wicks, allowing for the wicks to have room in the end to swell and absorb plenty of liquid to the point the liquid is sort of building up and soaking on the coils themselves.

Thirdly, a top coil design has no reason to make the slots, seals, and such "tight", as unless someone is storing the thing upside down (which I never do), then juice leaking into the head isn't really an issue, as these wicks can "swell" enough to take a ton of extra juice (especially if the juice is thick), and would, even with a gaping slot, catch enough liquid on our "twirls and swirls" to prevent any major leakage. This probably wouldn't be good for traveling and storing sideways or upside down, but for me, I simply want a working vape and I'd sacrifice anything just to have a system that really wicks in any sort of way.

Now, all this applies to normal heads as well, as I've done the same inspections and tests on those, yet I just can't even vape them because dry silica tastes so horrid to me - the hemp is really the only thing I can actually test so far without puking. Just, the dry hits are there, and these things just aren't wicking well. My recent experience with the iClear 30 was probably the worst wicking experience in any test I've done (Aspire, Protank II, ect ect all wicked slightly better) yet even on those devices, slightly dry wicks have given anything from off to horrid tastes. I can't really win with this and the only thing I can point it to is wicks that are dry to the point that, though generally moist, seem to dry up the second the battery is fired and singe from there.

I mean, if I were to rebuild a coil, it would only make sense to use something other than the wick itself to wrap the coil - something like a big plastic crochet needle and the wicks, so that the coil is quite loose and the wicks just sort of swell and sit in it; in devices that use wicks which have multiple strands, they're using so many strands that the wicks would fill up a coil that was virtually wrapped around a big drinking straw. Compressing all the strands down to the diameter of a piece of yarn, or smaller, just sort of bumfuzzles me as to how these things could possibly wick correctly, and the results don't show anything better. Sadly, the Smokin Crow heads (which, for anyone who doubts my methods, even the owner fessed up to issues with them once I bought it... ) were sort of my last resort in the non-rebuildable world, and from here on out, I guess my choices will be either take up rebuilding or quit vaping.

Has anyone here had any alike problems with wicking and CE5 type models or top feeders (or even bottom feeders)? I just seem to really see a lot of issues with factory-made coils, and my results aren't getting better. I am glad that many seem to get great results with such devices, but at the end of the day, something is just giving me a taste of constant dry silica or hemp, and it could merely be that my tongue is tremendously more sensitive to it than the tongues of others, but it's there, and I only seem to get a vape I enjoy when I vape a device where I can sit there and see that the wick is obviously soaked out the wazoo (for example, the first hit of a device that's been sitting there for days...) I just wish there was something I could do to solve this though, as no tricks seem to work, and rebuilding will be a major battle for me unless I happen to meet a kind stranger who could possibly build them for me and get me started.

I mean, when I look at folks' self-built heads, one type I see predominantly in the vaping world is the type where the coil is pre-wrapped around some sort of round thing (might as well be a pen for how big the coil wrap tends to look) and folks just seem to run a ton of cotton through it, and it just sits in there - half of the time not even filling up the coil. No spacing, none of that, just a coil "tube" of sorts. It's not the only style out there, but I sure doubt this style has any problems with wicking. And even with the general, normal rebuilt coils, like someone rebuiding a Protank head, they never seem that "tight" when it comes to a user who's wrapping because they really care about their own vape - it seems to be a goal in the rebuildable community to wrap things generally a little loose. This seems to give an absolute ton of vapor and wicking ability right off the bat, even for crazy ohm'd coils like 1.2 and such - the tank systems really have no reason that juice would simply be being delivered to the outer wicks any better.

At the end of the day, surely I'm not that wrong when it comes to assuming cotton isn't the only thing making rebuildables that much better. It would seem to require only simple manufacturing changes to get our simple little $10 devices to work and wick like a pro. But why isn't this done? Why am I having such extreme problems with wicking? I twirl, I prime, I drip, I pre-puff, I let it sit, I vape at 3.3V's, I do everything possible, and with my tests, I can't point to anything other than pre-built devices have coils that are simply wrapped way too tight.
 
Last edited:

nostinkies

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 30, 2013
276
213
Kayfun Nirvana!
Phew... I'm tired of reading and I bet your fingers are tired from typing. I do believe you have a vaild point. Here are a few of my observations.

The stock coils stink! Everyone knows that. My first attempt to improve this issue was to wrap 6 turns around silica wick, My coils worked exactly the same as the stock coils. Subpar at best.

Next I chose to wrap 6 turns of 32g kanthal wire around a 1/16" drill bit and then thread cotton yarn through the coil. Results have been much better than the stock setup. I too have often thought the grooves that allow the wick to exit the sides of the atty head "could" be a bit bigger to allow more cotton to seep to the coil. Unfortunately, there is a delicate balance between enhanced flavor and vapor production and causing the atty to become unreliable and exhibit excessive flooding due to a little thing called gravity.

Your solution is actually simple, Look at the bottom section of a kayfun, russian or clone and you'll see what properly designed juice channels look like that allow adequate juice flow and no flooding issues. As long as we continue to run these tiny little junk attys, your expressed issues will remain.

Solution: Get out your wallet and buy something better

If you design a better atty that can be used in protanks and every other 20 dollar tank, contact me and we"ll take it into production within a week.
 

GoodNews!

Moved On
Oct 25, 2013
577
136
Vaping, USA
Ya'll wanna know the strangest thing?

I vaped the first head from Mountain Vapors with one of the thinnest juices in my stock, and was getting very dry hits from it, eventually a burnt taste that wouldn't go away. I then soaked the head in water, and then, just to test, put some of VCV's 100% VG juice in the same clearomizer. For some absolutely strange reason, this juice, that is 10x thicker than the two juices I had already tested out with these heads, is not tasting dry at all, is producing quite a bit of vapor, and tastes okay. (Not strong flavor, but nothing bad.) What in the world gives? This thick-as-all-get-out juice seems to be working!

But yes, I think my route from here will be to get into the rebuildable tanks. It'll be a challenge, but I am absolutely fed up with smoking, I'm fed up with wasting money, I want a tank that, once I get that coil built, that the juice can channel into the coil all it truly needs to, and most of all, I'm having some pretty darn decent luck with hemp wicks, so rebuilding will allow me to keep at it if I prefer that over silica. It's just whew, another challenge.

I'm sort of wondering why this thick 100% VG juice is wicking a lot better than anything else in the Smokin Crow? Maybe VG really "sticks" on the wick and doesn't vaporize so quickly (causing the wick to dry out less?) The VG seems to wick so slowly that it's unreal (on physical tests) but I can't deny just how good this juice is suddenly the one working. There's little taste, but it tastes very clean, and this VG juice is also producing quite a ton of vapor for a single-coil. Hmmmm....
 
Last edited:

nostinkies

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 30, 2013
276
213
Kayfun Nirvana!
I can answer that one. It's just a matter of efficiency for the chinese. You can teach someone to wrap a wire around a wick and have them complete this task in 2seconds, but imagine the time it would take to make a coil and then thread a wick through it. It's about speed of production.

I read a thread tonight about someone sending an email to kanger about stinky burnt grommets. It gave me a laugh. The LAST thing kanger wants is us rebuilding THEIR coils. Thats counter productive. "So you turned up the volts too high and burnt your grommet in your 2dollar head?? We so sorry Joe, go to store and buying another one" It's all about the money and not really your satisfaction.
 

Utew

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Sep 16, 2013
178
242
Eugene, OR
I read a thread tonight about someone sending an email to kanger about stinky burnt grommets. It gave me a laugh. The LAST thing kanger wants is us rebuilding THEIR coils. Thats counter productive. "So you turned up the volts too high and burnt your grommet in your 2dollar head?? We so sorry Joe, go to store and buying another one" It's all about the money and not really your satisfaction.

Don't know if you've seen this or not... http://tasteyourjuice .com/wordpress/2013/10/04/nothing-like-some-new-heads/

(Remove space just before .com)
 
Last edited:

Subdivisions

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 23, 2013
433
360
PA

GoodNews!

Moved On
Oct 25, 2013
577
136
Vaping, USA
Well, it seems someone didn't put me on ignore because they still saw this thread.

But anyways, it's fine if all the vendor-employees here dislike my reviews, it doesn't effect me in the least. I don't educate people and tell the truth for popularity with the majority and neither did Martin Luther King. My initial review on this website was honest and reflected about 14 others' experiences with the Aspire, including one of Phil's buddies, and the people who experienced the problems appreciated the honesty. I already talked with Phil and he's been inquiring to Eigate himself. I believe profoundly that most beginner-level products (virtually anything that includes coils already in the product) are %75 of the time faulty, and with my experiences, I don't encourage their use as it is.

I also clearly have always stated that I review products intended for beginners, newbies, quick-vapers, and people on the go. I haven't reviewed any RBA's and I certainly don't plan to on a public level because, in my professional opinion, RBA's are not vaping devices, but rather devices that are additionally manufactured by the individual user to produce vapor. Harsh opinion, but I care more about people quitting cigarettes while avoiding faulty brands, rather than telling everyone and their mother to dive into a sub-hobby that virtually no one in the real world knows anything whatsoever about.

And yes, without a doubt, the Smokin' Crow CE5 rebuilt by Mountain Vapors is absolutely the best product I have tried over the span of non-RBA's. Does that mean it actually performs like a vaping device should? No. For some bizarre reason that a scientist would have to explain, it really only works with VG juice rather than PG, don't ask me why, I've already theorized. And for some other bizarre reason, while it tends to taste clean with VG, there's still almost no flavor even in comparison to the semi-wonky tastes I was getting out of the Aspire (the Aspire also initially did better with the same VG juice.)

I've simply had my share of working devices by our top name brands, I know how these things should perform, I've vaped for quite awhile, I have vaping buddies to test their own devices, I know the difference between a faulty head and a good head. %75 of the time, they're all bad, by every brand. Sure, it can fall down to luck who gets what, but I have bad luck in this, and yet I'm one of the few who are vocal about it. Other people in the same boat simply give up vaping entirely. I don't want that, as cigarettes really are an emotional and physical health problem, and I think every head out there should work as well as a Walmart Blender. Which is to say, always. And full refund if it doesn't, even if used.

So for whoever cares, if you're in the same boat, if no brand seems to give you anything but a burnt taste, try out the Smokin' Crow by Mountain Vapors, it'll kinda-sorta give you some good vaping if you use a really strong juice, VG at that, hemp is amazing compared to silica, yada yada. Until I happen to stumble on some good heads by silica brands, and until I can get the best RBA I can, I am sticking with the Smokin' Crow, it is not perfect, I wouldn't call it standard, but it's certainly better. I do have very in-depth a review up for it if anyone's interested. The owner of Mountain Vapors himself stated directly to me that his coils do have a good chance of being wrapped too tightly, he was more than supportive of sending me a free one, and after all that, I made the strange discovery that really, it was down to these particular wicks somehow just not working well with PG juice. VG solved the problem, even on the first head that I thought would never recover a clean taste.

One thing I'm also theorizing is that extremely thin juice does not work well with how tightly factory coils are wrapped, that they simply evaporate too quickly. I went out and bought the absolutely thinnest juices I could a couple months back (to test new products with) and got horrible results from all of them, dry hits galore. Maybe, just maybe, thicker juices or in-between juices actually wick best, and, since most here don't pay attention to juice thickness too much and probably use thicker juices, it may be why everyone's having luck. Not my fault, these devices should without a doubt work with very thin juices, but my devices aren't, and both the Aspire and Smokin' Crow worked better with VCV's 100%VG/Distilled mix.
 
Last edited:

bikerbeagle

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Oct 21, 2009
380
494
Wichita, KS USA
So for whoever cares, if you're in the same boat, if no brand seems to give you anything but a burnt taste, try out the Smokin' Crow by Mountain Vapors, it'll kinda-sorta give you some good vaping if you use a really strong juice, VG at that, hemp is amazing compared to silica, yada yada. Until I happen to stumble on some good heads by silica brands, and until I can get the best RBA I can, I am sticking with the Smokin' Crow, it is not perfect, I wouldn't call it standard, but it's certainly better. I do have very in-depth a review up for it if anyone's interested. The owner of Mountain Vapors himself stated directly to me that his coils do have a good chance of being wrapped too tightly, he was more than supportive of sending me a free one, and after all that, I made the strange discovery that really, it was down to these particular wicks somehow just not working well with PG juice. VG solved the problem, even on the first head that I thought would never recover a clean taste.
Just so I understand clearly ...what exactly are you saying (in 100 words or less)?

...you claim that "factory" coils are being wrapped too tight - all the while recommending a product that, as has been "stated directly" to you by the owner, also have a "good chance" of also being wrapped too tight ...

...you seem to claim Hemp is a better wicking material than Silica - all the while stating that it still doesn't wick well at all (but apparently tastes better when you dry hit?).

I'm not trying to be mean, but ...I hear you barking, Lassie, I just have no idea what it is you are saying. Is Timmy stuck in the well again?
 

TheJakeBailey

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 15, 2013
1,275
2,596
Austin,TX, USA
I really tried not to take the bait. I really did...

But anyways, it's fine if all the vendor-employees here dislike my reviews, it doesn't effect me in the least. I don't educate people and tell the truth for popularity with the majority and neither did Martin Luther King.

For the record, just so we are all clear... I am an insurance claims adjuster. I have never worked for any vendor or manufacturer of any vaping product. And I dislike your reviews, because they are not reviews. They are diatribes on how you can not get any product to work properly, and your speculation on why that may be. I think that they confuse newbies far more than they help, and they probably steer people away from products that could work very well for them.

But to compare your "reviews" with the work and accomplishments of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. is not even laughable, it's sad. You can't honestly justify that can you? Or do you know another Martin Luther King that you were referring to? Like a mechanic, or a dude at your grocery store? Please advise if I was incorrect.

including one of Phil's buddies, and the people who experienced the problems appreciated the honesty. I already talked with Phil and he's been inquiring to Eigate himself.

Name drop.


I've simply had my share of working devices by our top name brands, I know how these things should perform, I've vaped for quite awhile, I have vaping buddies to test their own devices, I know the difference between a faulty head and a good head. %75 of the time, they're all bad, by every brand.

While I admit, I don't stalk your profile, I have never heard you say much of anything positive about any device, ever. THAT, is why you get so much flak, and you don't get the assistance you want here. since you mentioned "Phil," (and again, assuming you meant taste your juice Phil, and not your accountant Phil) The reason he and others have such a following, is because they tell you both what is GOOD about a product, along with what might be bad, and why. This is what gets you credibility, and credibility is what you seem to be lacking. I might suggest telling us about these products that you have liked, and had success with, and WHY they worked for you. As far as the 75%, I think that most would agree that is completely unfounded, and if it were true, this forum wouldn't even exist.

The owner of Mountain Vapors himself stated directly to me that his coils do have a good chance of being wrapped too tightly, he was more than supportive of sending me a free one

It seems that most of the vendors that you often disparage have been more than willing to TRY to work with you and help you sort out your troubles. There comes a point though where any reasonable business would resort to cutting you off, as it seems that throwing more product at the problem is not going to fix it.


I honestly and sincerely wish you nothing but the best in your vaping journey, as I would to anyone kicking tobacco. I hope you find a product that you love, and I look forward to the day that you can come here and tell us all bout it!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread