That looks familiar! I think my wife has that exact tool in our bathroom drawer. I'm a little unsure whether the rounded end will be able to really get under the lip, but I'll give it a shot.
Very helpful! Thanks!
I think the paperclip I was using was just too small and the sharp end just tore right through the silicone not allowing me to get enough leverage. I have some long tweezers, but they don't have the curved tips like those. I'll need to try to find some like that. Any idea where you can get them? I already know Walmart doesn't carry anything like that...