The plot of where Penny will go thickens. I answered the barn owner's e-mail yesterday with this:
"I'll have to think this over. Penny gets frantic by herself. Maybe if we tried it, she'd get used to it, and maybe she would colic out of distress. There's no way to know. Certainly she could go out with your herd at night, but during the day, she would get very upset. Is there another horse you could keep with her?
If she stayed with your herd during the day, I might be able to handle Pete if I took a whip into the pasture every time and chased him far, far away. Would your herd be kept up near the barn during the day? Crossing that creek when it's full is more than I want to do.
Another option I considered was to see if Deb has room and keep Penny there for the winter. This would cost me a lot more, and I might have to dip into meager savings, so I'm not anxious to do that, but I might have to do it if Penny's welfare is at stake.
I'm racking my brains, trying to think of the best option. Help!"
And this morning, she sent this:
"This would not be just a winter thing so if you want to go to Deb's, a permanent move would be the thing to do. Honestly your decision to not let Penny be with Pete has been hard on her for an entire year now. She still continues to cry for that group when they go out to pasture. just the other day she was tossing her head at them repeatedly and circling and looking longingly at them from her pasture...As far as colic after all this time being upset, I doubt that would happen. She would only be a wire away from the others Plus I suggested her being able to be with them at night which is a hell of a lot better than never being with pete. You are so afraid of Pete that you have been blind to what Penny wants. Pete was acting like a horse, and didn't knock you over on purpose but he definitely acts differently when she is in heat then when Freska was. This is not all Pete's fault. Your horse rubs all over him! Maybe it has to do with where they fall in the herd order but it doesn't matter because I am going to put my horses together because they belong together and I no longer want them to be mixed with boarder horses, At least not during the day when an owner needs to get to them. I can't continue to let a boarder dictate where my horses are and what horses they are with. I do not want to separate Ali from her herd she has very strong feelings for. She also really likes king and Pete. Penny could care less about Ali, Flame and Wrangler. She was very content in the other group but I have given this a lot of thought and I need to do what is best for all the horses not just one. I also feel like you have gotten more and more worrisome and it is very hard to deal with. This thing between you and heather and the confusion about the feeding and pills is annoying. I am the adult, I am in charge and I know damn well that your horse is being cared for excellently. You told me that you were searching all around for Penny's feed and asking where it was. To Heather that was confusing because she thought you wanted penny to have it right then and there We have let you know when the pills were out and we have let you know when she needed more feed but all of a sudden you are worrying about it...?. We are in a switch of roles because you and heather have been confusing things! I have been moving Shelly back into the feeding schedule also because we now need to give out hay at 3 pm and Heather has NOT been feeding the horses at 3 for most all of this week. Instead she has been only opening gates and letting them out for me around 6 pm. Honestly I have no idea why you put those pills in the payment drop box...You have always been an overly worried horse owner, all the other places you were at have said the same thing about you, and yes I have talked to them all about you, you can be a challenge to please because you stress about everything and don't ever sway from your opinion. I am at a tired of it point... And this afternoon, why didn't you take her into one of the three pastures out back and brush her? Why do you always have to have her loose in my yard? OR why didn't you bring her through the back gate and around by the wooden horse feeder? This was the first time since you have been there that something was parked there like that. My husband and father in-law wanted to take all the wire and put it in the that old car they were scraping...it was a good thing to think of doing and I was thankful they did. There is a lot that happens on a horse farm that you have no idea about and I keep my feeding arrangements to myself because of the way you second guess everything and the last thing I need is you trying to tell me how to feed the horses. maybe it really would be a good thing for you to go back to Debs or somewhere else. I would be fine with taking your mention of it as notice that this will be her last month here."
It sounds like she wants me to leave. My fussiness over feeding Penny is that I insisted that she feed Penny twice a day. This is standard operating procedure at every barn where I've boarded Penny. It's well-known that feeding horses smaller meals more often is better for them, and some fancy barns even feed 3 times a day. I was also blamed for confusing her daughter. Heather is learning disabled, and she gets confused a lot. I was in the barn one day to check how low Penny's feed was getting, since I planned to go to Ithaca, where I buy feed, and if it was low enough, I wanted to pick up another bag while I was down there. Is that unreasonable? When Heather heard I was looking for Penny's feed, she got confused and thought I was saying to feed Penny then. As for leaving the pills in the drop box for board money, I had been doing that for months, and not a peep that it was not what the barn owner wanted me to do. How am I to know it's not where she wants me to leave them if she doesn't tell me? All in all, it sounds like she's very angry at me for inconveniencing her. I realize I'm a bit nit-picky about Penny's care and feeding, but I think any conscientious horse owner would be. Penny does need special care, since she gets feed that's different from the other horses and has a pill that has to be consumed daily. They missed giving the pill to Penny one day recently, even though I had left pills there, and that becomes my fault for leaving them where I've left them for months. No one said they were out of pills till yesterday -- and they weren't, since I had brought them about a week ago.
As for them blocking the way out of the pasture, they were loading a car with lots of old baling wire. OK, I understand that this doesn't happen all the time, and I stood there figuring out what to do. Since I couldn't take Penny out of her pasture, and since they had just given the horses their hay, I went into the pasture and groomed Penny while she ate. They noticed my frustration and that I didn't know what to do, but I never actually complained that they were blocking the way. And why am I not to take Penny out on the lawn to eat grass? The barn owner does this with her horses all the time, and she never mentioned that it bothered her.
I think my mention of going to Deb's was threatening her, and she went on a rant. Maybe, even if it will be financially difficult, i should move Penny. It's a shame, since the price is right, there are lovely pastures and trails, and the mud is minimal, but this isn't the first confrontation we've had, and I think it's a little crazy. Even if I'm to blame for being too nit-picky, I think I'm not totally to blame.