Coolest Menthol You've Found?

Status
Not open for further replies.

LFC

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 18, 2011
231
53
NC
Hello All,
My 510 arrived from cignot today, Tuesday, only ordered on Saturday afternoon so pleasantly surprised with the speed of shipping, thought it would be Wednesday at the earliest. My first PV and have been giving it a try this evening.

With the kit I also ordered their 2 Menthol sample packs, one in 12mg and one in 24mg, just to try and get an idea of Nic requirement. The juices were Chill #1, Chill #2 and the Big Chill.

My analogs were Camel Menthol Silvers, which have the 'Cool Burst' capsule in the filter, which I would crack before smoking them, making them 'extra cool'. Unfortunately I got used to this level of cool and any other Menthol analog was not cool enough for me.

The Big Chill is the coolest of the 3, it is VG only, and to be honest the 12mg is giving an OK TH, enough for me, but the coolness is not there... I am also experiencing a very dry feeing in my throat, but that may be just an adjustment I need to make, or the atty etc needs time for the shipping 'resin' to clear out, drinking plenty of water as suggested on here, we'll see how that goes. I have another order of juice due in a day or two, planned to mix PG/VG to find my best level, but none of the flavors ordered were menthol, figured I work out the mix levels then try some different menthol, hoped the starter menthol packs would do in the meantime.

I know this is pretty wordy, bottom line, hoping to find the coolest menthol you have tried so I can see if that does it for me :)

The advice I have received on here has been awesome, and on a plus note, I've only had one analog since I picked up the package at 4pm, now 11pm :) (and that was just to compare how much cooler it tasted.)
 

xnonfactor

Full Member
Jan 18, 2011
7
0
48
Dothan, AL
The closest Menthol I have found to an analog cigarette is Cool Rush by Liquid Xpress. The Cool Rush flavor they produce is bang on to a Kool Menthol Cigarette. I don't have any experience with the Camel Menthol you talked about, but if you like the flavor of a Kool it is worth picking up a bottle. I have tried all of the menthol flavors from Cignot and they don't hold a light to what I found from LiquidXpress Hompage. Mixed with a bit of flue cured tobacco from them and it is a mighty tasty vape. Even at 18 mg I get a monster throat hit on a LR 510 atty on an eGo.
 

jlarsen

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 23, 2011
499
59
Helena, MT
Halo Truepure is my all day everyday. But if you want a really strong menthol, I would suggest Vapor 4 Life Smilin Menthol or Halo Coolmist.

Best wishes, welcome and congratulations!

Have you tried all three of Halo's menthol flavors? It doesn't really say on the site, but I got the impression that Truepure was the least cool, and menthol ice the coolest, with coolmist in between. I'll be trying them in about 2 days when my shipment arrives. I have a buddy that smokes "Cool" analogs, and didn't care much for my Blu menthol cartridge when he tried it. I'd love to get him to switch to vaping, but it is probably going to take a liquid that is off the charts with menthol flavor to convince him.
 

Blueberry

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 17, 2011
128
27
52
France
Have you tried all three of Halo's menthol flavors? It doesn't really say on the site, but I got the impression that Truepure was the least cool, and menthol ice the coolest, with coolmist in between. I'll be trying them in about 2 days when my shipment arrives. I have a buddy that smokes "Cool" analogs, and didn't care much for my Blu menthol cartridge when he tried it. I'd love to get him to switch to vaping, but it is probably going to take a liquid that is off the charts with menthol flavor to convince him.

I personnally found the "Menthol Ice" too sweet, the truepure was the best of the 3 menthols available.
 

MsBree

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 27, 2010
562
140
New Jersey
www.precious-pets.org
I smoked menthols my entire 'career' for 33 years, so when I started vaping, I was on a mission to find that perfect menthol, which I never did find after spending a lot of money on lots of menthol samples from my different vendors! What I did learn about myself is that as long as I have a good tobacco base, I don't need the menthol anymore. The best tobacco juices for me are the ones made using FlavourArt flavorings, and I do know that FSUSA uses FlavourArt flavorings to make their juices! They have several yummy tobacco premixes on their site, and if you decide to try them, just ask them to add a splash of menthol when ordering! You will find that there is no juice that will ever exactly resemble real tobacco taste!
 

jlarsen

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Feb 23, 2011
499
59
Helena, MT
I personnally found the "Menthol Ice" too sweet, the truepure was the best of the 3 menthols available.

I like sweeter vapors and milder menthols (but not too mild). The friend I'm trying to convert probably won't be satisfied with anything less than pure menthol crystals packed into a crack pipe... but it's worth a try. I'm sure I'll like all of the Halo menthols.
 

player30

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 10, 2010
2,804
569
Birmingham AL
I have tried all three and I buy all three. Truepure is definitely my favorite followed by Coolmist and then Menthol Ice. I do enjoy swapping out every now & then. To me M I has a nint of tobacco flavor in it.

Have you tried all three of Halo's menthol flavors? It doesn't really say on the site, but I got the impression that Truepure was the least cool, and menthol ice the coolest, with coolmist in between. I'll be trying them in about 2 days when my shipment arrives. I have a buddy that smokes "Cool" analogs, and didn't care much for my Blu menthol cartridge when he tried it. I'd love to get him to switch to vaping, but it is probably going to take a liquid that is off the charts with menthol flavor to convince him.
 

PKZap27

Resting In Peace
ECF Veteran
Jan 22, 2011
1,848
675
USA - Ohio
I've use the menthol drops from JuicyLiquid to add a good menthol kick to my juices.

Specialty Ingredients : JuicyLiquid.com, DIY E-Liquid and Accessories!

It's pretty strong so I would use about 1 drop per ml or less to start with.

The "Coolest Menthol I've Found"?

That would have to be my DIY menthol mix.

I mixed to much menthol flavoring in a menthol mix I was making (menthol, peppermint & Creme De Menthe) and...

WOW! That was the coolest menthol hit I ever had by far. LOL
 

xg4bx

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Aug 5, 2010
1,216
403
Phillipsburg, New Jersey
I smoked menthols my entire 'career' for 33 years, so when I started vaping, I was on a mission to find that perfect menthol, which I never did find after spending a lot of money on lots of menthol samples from my different vendors! What I did learn about myself is that as long as I have a good tobacco base, I don't need the menthol anymore. The best tobacco juices for me are the ones made using FlavourArt flavorings, and I do know that FSUSA uses FlavourArt flavorings to make their juices! They have several yummy tobacco premixes on their site, and if you decide to try them, just ask them to add a splash of menthol when ordering! You will find that there is no juice that will ever exactly resemble real tobacco taste!

Try purecig menthol from fsusa, it literally tastes like a menthol cig, its a perfect blend of menthol and tobacco. Its not too minty nor too "icy", its dead-on menthol cig flavor.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread