Well, OP, as you can see.....you have gotten quite of few suggestions as to what menthol to try.
But these suggestions are all subjective to what "tastes good" to that particular person.
I was a 35 + year menthol smoker and when I started vaping....getting the right "juice" was by
far the largest obstacle to overcome.
The perfect menthol vape juice.....
for me....was not out there.
I tried well over 25 or so brand name
juices, all toooooo strong of a taste, vicks rub taste, and just pure jucky taste in most of what I tried.
But I was determined. I kept trying, mixing, ordering, trying, mixing up different combos, etc.
Most menthols...are way to mentholy (?) and not enough tobacco flavor. What I read here, is that alot
of the seasoned menthol vapers, have used cinnamon as part of their menthol blend.
So I tried that. And it worked.
I have now settled into
MY perfect mix.
1/2 Pure Smokers....either "Fire & Ice....or "Firecracker" (both cinnamon type flavor but NOT overpowering)
and 1/2 Johnson Creek Domestic Tobacco (Red Oak line all VG)
To that I add a few drops of straight PG (too much PG drying my face, skin etc. out)
I have been on this "mix" for several months....and love it.
So perhaps give a cinnamon mix with a tobbaco flavor added a try.
I cannot tell you how happy I am that I did not give up finding the "perfect" mix.
As you can see by my sig, I am now into my 8th month.....NO ANALOGS!
I feel soooo much better.....breath sooooo much better......lost the cough, found "smell"
again and many many more benefits that changing to vaping has helped me with.
So my moral to my long story is......don't give up. She is so lucky to have someone like
you giving her support and help along the way.
What works for some, may not work for others. Taste is very subjective to each of us.
Keep up the good work, for both of you!