Giving up on e-cigarette

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tinkiegrrl

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2013
3,013
3,480
New York, NY
So who wants to talk about vaping and not snuff and perscriptions?

It's all related. There are, indeed, medical reasons why something more the nicotine may be needed. Snus and other forms of smokeless tobacco contains them. Your premise that there's no reason to need this is false.
 

supermarket

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2010
1,401
1,852
Near Atlanta, Georgia, US of A
orlly?? the term harm reduction is everywhere. we're here to support each other; the vast majority have no false expectations about all of this.

I beg to differ.

I see a lot of people here who seem to get angry or upset at anyone who hints at the possibility that e-cigs might not be safe. Of course, they often times try to defend themselves by saying something like, "Of course it MIGHT not be...." or "nothing is 100% safe", or "At least it is safer than cigarettes! No tar!"


Just seeing everyone jump on this guy is kind of icky. He wasn't offensive. He didn't insult or attack anyone. He made a thread basically saying , "Look guys, I wasn't a smoker...and e-cigs aren't working out for me. I have some health concerns, and therefore won't be vaping anymore..."

Seems fine to me.

Seeing people tell him to go buy cigarettes , to me isn't funny. It is like basically telling him to go die, in a subtle way. He wasn't a smoker.....I could see if he came on here and started saying "I have concerns about e-cigs....I don't think they are safe. I'm going to switch back to cigarettes" then I could see people giving him a hard time. For what he posted though? Sorry.....I think everyone is being over-zealous.
 

tnt56

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 30, 2012
6,592
11,481
68
Tripple digits half way to home
Personally I Vape NET's and WTA e juice at 18-24 mg. I also use snus. My lung doc says do what ever it takes to keep from smoking.

I also believe your comments about CASAA are uncalled for.

One of the moderators needs to put a stop to this type of discussion ASAP.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

kristin

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
10,448
21,120
CASAA - Wisconsin
casaa.org
Looks like I'm going to be giving up on e-cigarettes. The first reason is that I shorted out my battery by getting juice on it. The second reason is that it seems that the jury is out on the safety of wick materials. Silica is said to fragment and be inhaled, and cotton, even if organic, is bleached with hydrogen peroxide, which is an oxidizer, not something to be inhaled. I would assume that the amount of hydrogen peroxide in a cotton ball is minuscule, but unless the safety of wick materials can be verified 100%, it's just not a gamble I'm willing to take.

Granted for someone who is getting off of cigarettes the harm reduction would be immense, but since I don't smoke cigarettes and am not trying to get off smoking tobacco, there is no reason to risk using e-cigs, even though the risks are probably low. I'm sure other people have had the same thoughts on the subject.

Unfortunate because I enjoy the taste and vapor of e-cigs over the occasional cigarette I used to smoke everyone once in a while. Now I guess I'll quit cold turkey and not puff on anything. Oh well. Maybe if a verdict is reached on silica wicks or a safe wick material is introduced into the market I will look into it.

Edit: This thread might have been better placed in the health and safety sub-forum, I have no objection to it being moved.

The great thing about e-cigarettes is that it offers a lot of choices and options. Many people use them to reduce their health risks and some use them to wean off nicotine - it's that ability to choose that is so important. You choose not to accept even the small risks of vaping and you shouldn't feel bad about that. It doesn't negate the fact that even the highest risks of vaping are far lower than smoking for those who smoked before, so don't worry about it. All vapers should support people's right to CHOOSE and you choose not to vape.

In all honesty, if you smoked rarely, your health risks weren't that high to begin with (not that I recommend smoking AT ALL.) For smokers, reducing smoking from a pack a day to a couple a day significantly reduces health risks, so someone who who smokes only a few once in a while (like a pack a month or something) doesn't have the same high risks as a pack-a-day smoker (again, NOT recommending you continue smoking!) BUT keep in mind that your risks from occasionally vaping - even with the silica wicks and cotton question - are likely still lower than the risks from occasionally smoking, so please don't go back to smoking occasionally vs. vaping occasionally or quitting altogether. :)
 

Tinkiegrrl

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2013
3,013
3,480
New York, NY
I beg to differ.

I see a lot of people here who seem to get angry or upset at anyone who hints at the possibility that e-cigs might not be safe. Of course, they often times try to defend themselves by saying something like, "Of course it MIGHT not be...." or "nothing is 100% safe", or "At least it is safer than cigarettes! No tar!"


Just seeing everyone jump on this guy is kind of icky. He wasn't offensive. He didn't insult or attack anyone. He made a thread basically saying , "Look guys, I wasn't a smoker...and e-cigs aren't working out for me. I have some health concerns, and therefore won't be vaping anymore..."

Seems fine to me.

Seeing people tell him to go buy cigarettes , to me isn't funny. It is like basically telling him to go die, in a subtle way. He wasn't a smoker.....I could see if he came on here and started saying "I have concerns about e-cigs....I don't think they are safe. I'm going to switch back to cigarettes" then I could see people giving him a hard time. For what he posted though? Sorry.....I think everyone is being over-zealous.

I agree that there are a great number of zealots around. I've always disagreed with the types who go around calling people ANTZ for feeling it was impolite to blow clouds in certain situations, or saying that e-cigarettes are 100% safe. They are safer then cigarettes, hence why they are called a harm reduction tool. If the original poster was never addicted to cigarettes, then why should he take any risk at all? I will say this though. Rather then smoke an occasional cigarette, I'd rather he vaped occasionally.
 

supermarket

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jul 2, 2010
1,401
1,852
Near Atlanta, Georgia, US of A
Personally I Vape NET's and WTA e juice at 18-24 mg. I also use snus. My lung doc says do what ever it takes to keep from smoking.

I also believe your comments about CASAA are uncalled for.

One of the moderators needs to put a stop to this type of discussion ASAP.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Ugh.

I don't like what I see, so please, someone moderate it!

I admit perhaps the guy came off a little harshly, but then again, so did 20+ people on the original poster of this thread, for HIS opinions.

Instead of having a moderator come and lock up a thread and ban/punish a user here....why not let the posts speak for themselves?
 

MonoNatural

Moved On
Jun 5, 2009
48
10
Ugh.

I don't like what I see, so please, someone moderate it!

I admit perhaps the guy came off a little harshly, but then again, so did 20+ people on the original poster of this thread, for HIS opinions.

Instead of having a moderator come and lock up a thread and ban/punish a user here....why not let the posts speak for themselves?

Ive been told by a mod that talking here is a privilege and not a right, and that there is no way to know what topics arent allowed until you get punished for it :( And also that my "agenda will cease"...yikes!
 

hittman

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Contest Winner!
  • Jul 13, 2009
    61,637
    180,084
    Somewhere between here and there
    I just read back thru this thread and it still amazes me how fast a thread can go south of the topic brought up by the OP. The OP has what they consider to be legitimate concerns and actually got a bit of decent feedback and some people trying to offer assistance while others chose to go on the attack and offer the advice of going back to smoking. Is that really how we want to be portrayed as a community? I think not.

    I started out almost five years ago with my first ecig in hopes of quitting smoking after 23 years. I did quit after a few months but felt myself sinking into depression. I am one of the ones that does not function well without the minor alkaloids found in tobacco. Some folks suggested I try Swedish snus. I had always thought of smokeless tobacco as a gross habit that I wouldn't consider. I did as much reading and research as I could on the risk factors of snus and finally decided to give it a try. For me it was the "something missing" that I needed to stay level. I'm not saying that everyone that struggles should go buy snus but it is a reduced risk option that is much safer than smoking just as I believe vaping is much safer. WTA was not available to the public back then but I also believe that wta is a useful reduced risk option for those that need the minor alkaloids that regular nicotine liquids don't deliver. Just to be open, I use snus, regular eliquids, and wta eliquids.
     

    rothenbj

    Vaping Master
    Supporting Member
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jul 23, 2009
    8,285
    7,707
    Green Lane, Pa
    Does anyone remember an old cartoon about two chemists going out for dinner? I can't find it but the dialogue goes as follows:

    Waiter: Gentlemen, what would you like to drink?

    1st Chemist: I'll have a glass of H2O.

    2nd Chemist: I'll have a glass of H2O too.

    The drinks arrive and they toast each other and drink up.

    The second chemist keels over and dies...
    -
    If you haven't seen it, it takes a while to get it but it seems to be topical to this thread.


     

    humangraffiti

    Senior Member
    ECF Veteran
    Feb 22, 2014
    147
    27
    United States
    Was going to state the same, no idea why someone would pick up vaping when they weren't a smoker first but to each their own. I guess it is a "reduced harm alternative" and would be better for someone to pick up vaping rather than smoking, just not an expected path to me.

    OP: I can't argue with your points especially if you were not vaping to avoid smoking, really do wish you the best of luck!

    I started vaping coz i thought it was cool. Never got into smoking cigareettes. Now im all into vaping haha


    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread