Respectfully, I feel a bit different. As I have many very nice ss mesh set ups and love to wrap a mesh wick. I have compared and compared silica and mesh for a very long time.
GVC has become an addiction of mine and this is my thought. Mesh gets very hot and the taste varies throughout the tank to me and it wrecks the mesh as there is a need to torch the mesh often to burn the residual sugars to maintain taste as a dry burn or two does not work as the residual is embedded deep. And, every time the mesh is torched it creates a new layer of oxidation and eventually will ruin the new clean taste quickly. It is also creates hot spots within the mesh, distorting it and crating holes(oxidation is not healthy).
Silica also gums up a bit due to the coagulation of sugar residue especially in small evaporation chambers as there is less area to dissipate the residue. But, the taste is very consistent with GVC used with silica medium. Silica is a snap to rinse and dryburn - maintain when needed. I think there is no comparison to my tobacco flavors as silica/cotton/ekowool win hands down in flavour to me. Even as I sit here I can not get over the flavour of the spheroid. Yes my S Turbine produces clouds like a burning mobile home but I am into flavor now more so than CLOUDS but, I will also tell you the clouds the Spheroid produce are amazing as well.
Looking at my set ups and the evolution of my collection, I have no ss in my GP rotation right now or the few GG's I use.
The fun part is finding what suits you the best. This is also what makes us a diverse community and how we all learn from one another.
Very true Brother, this is why you are the King.