Thanks so much everyone! It is very encouraging that I'm not alone in this transition. I was beginning to think something was very wrong if I still wanted analogs.
I have a pretty good model for me, I think. It's a VK 808. I'm having a trouble with consistency in vapor production, but I've ordered some PG juice and maybe that will help. The biggest thing for me is to realize there will always be some elements of analog smoking that will never be replicated but that I will actually come to enjoy vaping more and more.
I just tried some of my husband's brand-spanking-new 36 mg cartomizers and I think those do the trick, so I'm definitely upping my nicotine. Since he started vaping today I think I've seen him go outside for an analog maybe once or twice! I don't like the flavors he got though, so I'll have to order my own.
I hadn't smoked an analog in 2-3 hours and just went outside to have one. This time of the evening, after putting kids to bed, I usually smoke 2 or 3 in a row outside. I had one, it was marginally satisfying, but actually preferred to come in and start vaping on my yummy carto.
Anyway, thanks so much for the pep talks.

It gives me hope that several of you were able to gradually decrease the analogs and that some day analogs will no longer appeal to me.