The good thing about the i4 is it stops when the batteries are fully charged. I leave mine on it till i need them. So i always have 2 fully charged and 2 in my mod. Remembering to swap out before i leave for work, now thats a different story.It will depend on how low they were to begin with. I’ve personally found Batteries commonly come from distributors around half full. It’s common for a battery to need at least several hours to charge. It’s going to vary a lot though. My personal behavior (which others are going to say is less than safe and they’re not wrong) is to leave them to charge overnight and if they’re not charged by morning there’s probably some sort of issue.
I have nitecore i4 too and 5 VTC4. What I find faulty about this old charger is if I use all 4 slots, one of them will "false full" (all three LED lights up)... SO when charging, I only use two or three slots, not all four. From empty to full, it takes about 2.5 to 3 hours to charge those VTC4. I have no idea about your battery though.
I also have two I-JOY INR 26650... Both can off center fit in the i4 charger but the same fault will happen. One will "false full"... So I charge them one at a time. Six hours from empty to full. That's from the day I bought them, or "initial charge". After that, I was never able to use up the 26650s and charge them even though they are still have full. From half full to full charge, 2 hours give or take.
Best charging practice I've heard round, is to charge at half the capacity.
For example, 2000mAh = 1A. It's the fastest you can do without stressing batteries.