I see both sides here, as a long time customer perhaps a phone call was in order and may have resulted in a different outcome. Them, I can see they just can't take back any juice (most vendors won't) so they can check it, it may have been mislabeled folks do make mistakes. I would chalk it up to a mistake pay a few bucks and send it back, you most likely would have been given a few goodies to cover the expense. Finding a juice you really like is hard enough and to order that much of it you must like it. But in the end you have to choose what to do. Sorry this happened to you.