If I like this, what do you think I would also like....

[jjcordone]

I exchanged a PM with Mr.Mann decided I'd do this as a tread.
Please do respond here with your advice.
I've spent a bundle of juices selecting by trial and error.
I can't afford to continue selecting ones I don't like.

I've settled into 12mg nic, 100% VG, tobacco flavors as being my sweet spot.
I've been trying some of the premium juices I see good postings on and I'm hoping to find some more.
I'll list below the ones I've liked and I'll give one I don't like.
Based on these, what would you recommend for me to try?

Thanks everyone!

Don't like - please don't take this as a knock the fans of this one our there and especially the manufacturer.
Excellent customer service and fast delivery, this specific juice just isn't for me...
Johnson Creek Red Oak Series - Silverthorn. To me it has a perfume type taste that I noticed right away.
I have the bottle listed in the classifieds and I'm open to a swap if there's a fan of this one reading this....

My favorites
Ahlusion - House Blend
Cooper Creek - House Blend
Vermillion River - Kentucky Premium Blend
Heathers Heavenly Vapers - Gandalf
AVE - Boba's Bounty
RAWR - Poison
Mom and Pops - RYO tobacco

So, if I like these and I don't like that, what do you think I would also like?

Thanks everyone!

 

[Mr.Mann]

My favorites
Ahlusion - House Blend
Cooper Creek - House Blend
Vermillion River - Kentucky Premium Blend
Heathers Heavenly Vapers - Gandalf
AVE - Boba's Bounty
RAWR - Poison
Mom and Pops - RYO Tobacco

Kentucky Amaretto Blend from Vermillion River? Based on you liking KPB.

Have you tried Huntsman from HHV? Based on you liking Gandalf.

What about Vecchio from Ahlusion? Based on you liking House Blend.

 

[seneka]

Swagger from Pink Spot Vapors is REALLY yummy.

 

[gthompson]

Swagger from Pink Spot Vapors is REALLY yummy.

I agree, one of my favs, but it isn't real "tobacco-y".

 

[EleanorR]

Vermillion River's KPB Maplewood and KPB Applewood are both excellent, too.

 

[SubOnAux24]

You may like Mountain Oak Vapors MOV Gold, Tennessee or their 555 version. They are a sweet vape but not over the top. Vape On !

 

[puff-a-saurus]

I don't like johnson Creek either

 

[Racehorse]

've settled into 12mg nic, 100% VG, tobacco flavors as being my sweet spot.

There's a number of us on that same "train". Keep looking in PIF swap? I've found a number of people to trade with as well who I know like 100% VG.

Silverthorn is described as a pipe or cigar like tobacco I think. That would account for the perfumy...

 

[Highwayman1224]

KPB Vanilla isn't bad

 

[lasttango]

I thought you tried everything JJ ;-)
I know you are a BWB fan too... so... we do have similar tastes in non-menthols....

Definitely the dark honey tobacco from Aroma... They might be making it without wta... it was in the works anyway...
It's from their red tail line... and it doesn't taste like honey ;-) it very much fits into the category you descrobed as your likes... semi/mildly sweet... deep complex flavors... tons of vapor... VG juice. it's a winner. I told jerry he had a legend on his hands... and it could very well be one... Dark Honey Tobacco E-Cigarette Refill with WTA Red Tail Vapor

another to consider... that might work well for you is bluemist's caramel tobacco... in VG... it was quite a surprise... got a sample, and then bought 180mls of it. I'm sure you are familiar with Bluemist... I was quite lackluster about them after trying the robacco juices... and I was hesitant to try them again... I am glad I did... I found three winners there... and I would suggest trying the caramel tobacco in VG... it's quite inexpensive... but well made. It's mild in flavor, so get double flavor if you need intense flavor. I prefer the single flavoring.

...and I am still sampling these... are some of the plume room's concoctions... andrea... their mixer is as good as they get...
She mixes a home brewed fresh leaf steeped with some pretty interesting flavors... In particular I liked the honey-fig and the candy cavendish... my only complaint is performance... at 5 volts, they didn't consistently perform... but the steeped tobaccos have this problem... dark... juices... again, it's the fresh leaf steeped... much like BWB's adirondack... or vaperite's organics... I only like a few of these steeped tobaccos... and these are two of them.

 

[Hulamoon]

Hey LT (being held by a strange man ROFL). I'm going to have to watch your recommendations closely! +1 from me on dark honey from Aroma - Red Tail ( I do have the WTA) in fact I have about 40-50 ml of the stuff, and ALSO BMV - only my 180 ml = Blackjack. Love the stuff - it was my first and I still use it on a daily basis. And I have to find stuff to trade for the eJoker. Love the stuff. You're ahead of me on ThePlumeRoom but I've heard many good things about them.

I thought you tried everything JJ ;-)
I know you are a BWB fan too... so... we do have similar tastes in non-menthols....

Definitely the dark honey tobacco from Aroma... They might be making it without wta... it was in the works anyway...
It's from their red tail line... and it doesn't taste like honey ;-) it very much fits into the category you descrobed as your likes... semi/mildly sweet... deep complex flavors... tons of vapor... VG juice. it's a winner. I told jerry he had a legend on his hands... and it could very well be one... Dark Honey Tobacco E-Cigarette Refill with WTA Red Tail Vapor

another to consider... that might work well for you is bluemist's caramel tobacco... in VG... it was quite a surprise... got a sample, and then bought 180mls of it. I'm sure you are familiar with Bluemist... I was quite lackluster about them after trying the robacco juices... and I was hesitant to try them again... I am glad I did... I found three winners there... and I would suggest trying the caramel tobacco in VG... it's quite inexpensive... but well made. It's mild in flavor, so get double flavor if you need intense flavor. I prefer the single flavoring.

...and I am still sampling these... are some of the plume room's concoctions... andrea... their mixer is as good as they get...
She mixes a home brewed fresh leaf steeped with some pretty interesting flavors... In particular I liked the honey-fig and the candy cavendish... my only complaint is performance... at 5 volts, they didn't consistently perform... but the steeped tobaccos have this problem... dark... juices... again, it's the fresh leaf steeped... much like BWB's adirondack... or vaperite's organics... I only like a few of these steeped tobaccos... and these are two of them.

 

[jjcordone]

Thank you all for the advice on this thread, I'm going to give some of these a try and I'll post here what I find.

racehorse and puff-a-saurus: I really pondered how to post what I said without offending anyone.
Johnson Creek is an excellent company. They did little customer service touches that I admire.
Their packaging is superior, from the bottles they use to the box its shipped in.
I wasn't sure if I was the only one who picked up on the perfume type flavor, I'm sensitive to it in any juice.
I'm sure their are a lot of folks out there who love their products and to them I say vape on, it's all good

lasttango - I'll check out the Aroma line. I have used their WTA flavors and I really liked them, but the WTA juices are just too expensive for me to use on a regular basis. Maybe their red tail line without WTA is more competitively priced?
I smiled when you mentioned Bluemist. I have a bottle of Robacko and I do like it. I do suspect they use an alcohol based flavor mix in it, again I pick up on the alcohol flavor immediately, but I don't mind it.
Bluemist pricing is amazing and they ship very fast!

I got PM's on the RAWR poison that I mentioned. IMO - it is a lighter flavor and I believe they describe it as being a potential base for some upcoming flavored tobaccos they are planning. Nice all day vape type of juice.
Here's picture of the bottle I have so you can see it's color....
View attachment 133231

 

[AuBadge]

You might also like 'French Pipe' from Highbrow Vapor.