Gotta say that I back the OP's opinion.
I've seen a thousand instances of newbs being steered away from devices that may work very well for them, and pointed towards others that, while they may also work very well, might not be the best fit.
I see it happening most often when no real information is offered by the newb, and members will throw suggestions without any real justification eg: "get a eGo coz I luv it, it's da best, fugheddabout everything else", Zero information offered, zero value responses abound.
Of course then it becomes a catfight (not proud to say I've gotten involved once or twice) and people side off into two or three different camps and staunchly defend their positions using infallible logic, sometimes circular logic, put downs, healthy doses of bias, extreme and irrelevant points of view taken to varied lengths, and the occasional douche that pipes up to suggest a high end mod as a first PV because "why bother? You know you'll get one eventually."
Let's not forget the "Prove it!" junkies, and the folks that will lump all small ecigs into the same basket or rubbish a PV they have never used.
All I'm saying is it's funny how even though we preach "one size does not fit all" many will still say this and in the very next sentence proclaim their choice as the only model worth considering. LOL @ that.
Because of all this I try my hardest these days to stay away from "What model should I get?" newbie posts unless their list of criteria is very clear, or I ask them for heaps more info if I'm first in and they haven't offered it.
Buying a mall starter kit for $200 is a mistake, but only if you know better. Badgering newbs (however gently and diplomatically) into buying a certain model only because we like it, and dislike what they seem to be most likely to buy and happily use is "our" mistake.