I have ZERO experience with any red wine concentrates. I can't even think of how to advise.Also either 0.3 or 0.4% FA Red Wine to both recipes — help me decide.
I might suggest a side-by-side testing of cream vs. marshmallow (not combined). Cream may very well add the missing component. I do NOT have near the practical on-hand experience that mixers like PJReid has. PJ knows what works for her, and what doesn't... through her own practical application and testing.I will hold off adding more Fresh Cream to #1 for the time being so see what happens with the Marshmallow.
I am still 80% hypothetical, and only 20% practical. One thing I am still learning... with much resistance... is real life applications, don't always translate to vaping. I still have to start out with the simplest of "either/or" trials. More subtle "combinations" elude me until I can differentiate any differences.
PJ has already put in this work.
And you are NOT the least bit wrong.I agree with you, for the most part. I use marshmallow in liqueur flavors often. Meringue works well too. There are some liqueur flavors that mix well with creams and give the mix the perception of creamy richness. I thought cream was worth a try for @NotSoMini 's Creme de Cassis but it might be that something with the perception of syrup might work better, or a combination. Experimentation.

I still tend to think in the terms of "black and white." You have a much better understanding/experience to paint with countless shades of grey.
Your evaluations, and perceptions, have been immeasurable to me. You have broadened my own awareness(?) to flavor evaluation. I do not always share your same result; but you have always added a more thorough understanding (evaluation?) to concentrates we both have tried. You tend to offer thought, comparison, and perception. I always value your input
