Looking for a good menthol juice

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California
Been off the analogs, and vaping for a few days now. I smoked 2+ packs a day of Marlboro menthol lights. So I'm looking for a decent menthol. Ordered one menthol juice when I got my e-ceg and I don't really like it. More minty then menthol and not really that good. Pretty sure it was Dekang juice. I also tried Vermont Vapor's menthol, and I Like that, and will probably get more. Also just ordered some menthol from Widows bead work. Hopefully I'll like that. But I'm wondering what some of you more experienced people who like menthol prefer.

Ez
 
I make my own.
sign0076.gif


http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/diy-e-liquid/20590-menthol-drops-recipe-menthol-lovers.html

- -
Okay,
Father Luke
 

SquirrilahFish

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 5, 2009
328
2
38
Honolulu
ive tried regular menthol vape, and i agree very minty, almost like a NEWPORT, MY favorite menthol, actually my favorite juice at the moment, is JOHNSONS CREEK ARCTIC MENTHOL< by far their best flavor, different from anything else out there, Its definetly menthol, but kinda reminds me of mint chocolate chip ice cream, i love it!
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
Been off the analogs, and vaping for a few days now. I smoked 2+ packs a day of Marlboro menthol lights. So I'm looking for a decent menthol. Ordered one menthol juice when I got my e-ceg and I don't really like it. More minty then menthol and not really that good. Pretty sure it was Dekang Juice. I also tried Vermont Vapor's menthol, and I Like that, and will probably get more. Also just ordered some menthol from Widows bead work. Hopefully I'll like that. But I'm wondering what some of you more experienced people who like menthol prefer.

Ez

I'm a life long menthol smoker - Salems.
My favorite has been 'Newport':

FS Nwpt eLiquid - freshsmoking.com

Although there is a contender:

HIGH VOLTAGE SAMPLERS 12Mg 6ml Plastic Dropper Bottles

I have tried and liked the "Nuport" and because it is so good I intend to try the 'Menthol 555' on the next order.

All others that I've tried pretty much taste the same - menthol. The above have tobacco and menthol.

If you try freshsmoking's Newport you could also grab some menthol crystals there:

FS Menthol Crystals - freshsmoking.com

note the tip on how to use it below the picture.
 

808hustlin

Full Member
Jul 29, 2009
38
0
Maui, HI
I've tried 3 Menthol's so far Ecopure Menthol High / Med, Nhaler's 555 Menthol & Nhaler's Nuport. I liked Nuport had a great menthol flavor but was a little bit strong for me. 555 menthol was good but had a nutty taste that became too much when using it as my primary vape. While testing these I also found that I have allergies to PG and now can only vape VG. Ecopure has been my primary vape since i got my 510 from innovapor but i'd like to find one with a little more menthol flavor. If anyone knows of a good VG based menthol please let me know i'd love to try em.
 
Last edited:

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California

So how good is it? Because it sounds pretty good:) I may have try this.

ive tried regular menthol vape, and i agree very minty, almost like a NEWPORT, MY favorite menthol, actually my favorite juice at the moment, is JOHNSONS CREEK ARCTIC MENTHOL< by far their best flavor, different from anything else out there, Its definetly menthol, but kinda reminds me of mint chocolate chip ice cream, i love it!
Yeah that does sound good, and I actually got a choco mint sample from Vermont vapor that is very good. Kind of like mint choc chip ice cream.

I'm a life long menthol smoker - Salems.
My favorite has been 'Newport':

FS Nwpt eLiquid - freshsmoking.com

Although there is a contender:

HIGH VOLTAGE SAMPLERS 12Mg 6ml Plastic Dropper Bottles

I have tried and liked the "Nuport" and because it is so good I intend to try the 'Menthol 555' on the next order.

All others that I've tried pretty much taste the same - menthol. The above have tobacco and menthol.

If you try freshsmoking's Newport you could also grab some menthol crystals there:

FS Menthol Crystals - freshsmoking.com

note the tip on how to use it below the picture.

The high voltaage doesn't interest me because I want at least 20 mg nic. But I may try the nuport liquid. I've read 4 or 5 other posts also saying good things about it. And I may get some of those crystals. Would help to spice up a weak menthol.

I've tried 3 Menthol's so far Ecopure Menthol High / Med, Nhaler's 555 Menthol & Nhaler's Nuport. I liked Nuport had a great menthol flavor but was a little bit strong for me. 555 menthol was good but had a nutty taste that became too much when using it as my primary vape. While testing these I also found that I have allergies to PG and now can only vape VG. Ecopure has been my primary vape since i got my 510 from innovapor but i'd like to find one with a little more menthol flavor. If anyone knows of a good VG based menthol please let me know i'd love to try em.
See... there's another person singing the praises of Nuport. I really think I may have to try this one.


If you have found a good tobacco flavor that you like, you could get a bottle of menthol drops and just add a few drops to taste. Gives a nice menthol kick, not a minty spearmint taste.
hmm. Father Luke was saying how good the home made drops were. I think I may try that also.


So Far I have tried Menthol from Truesmoker which I bought at the same time I got my 401 Dragon. Not really that good, at least not to me. It's not really menthol, more like peppermint. Kind of weak throat hit also. Not what I'm looking for.
I also got some samples from Vermont vapor when I first ordered my PV, and menthol was one of em. Their menthol so far, is the best I've had. It's colorless, and has a refreshing menthol taste. Not like a mint. Not to strong, but very good flavor, good throat hit, and good vapor. Every time I used it, I would look at my PV after a hit and think, 'This is really good". So far, it's what I will judge others by until I find better. (Or make better).
I ordered more a few days ago and can't wait till it gets here.

I also tried some of the widows menthol from Widows Bead work, based on what I read. Got it in today and was VERY disappointed. I got the 24mg, so you would think it would have some kick to it. Nope. It's more of a tobacco flavor with a mild menthol taste. Weak vapor, weak throat hit, not what I expected and a big letdown.

So for now, I'll be using the Vermont menthol as my main vape of choice, until I find something better, and I think I'll also be looking into that recipe that Father Luke recommended.

Ez :)
 
Last edited:

RenaissancePuffer

Unregistered Supplier
ECF Veteran
I've only tried the ECOPure Menthol V-HI, and it is actually pretty good. I was a Marlboro Lights Menthol smoker before I began vaping. Ironically, I don't really vape menthol at all, maybe once every other day for about 5-6 puffs. I've been giving RY4 a lot of attention lately, or my own DIY mixtures.
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
The high voltaage doesn't interest me because I want at least 20 mg nic. But I may try the nuport liquid. I've read 4 or 5 other posts also saying good things about it. And I may get some of those crystals. Would help to spice up a weak menthol.

See... there's another person singing the praises of Nuport. I really think I may have to try this one.

EZ,

Sorry I should have been more specific. Nhaler/Drew - see the suppliers forum - has mostly 24mg juice. I just grabbed that link because I had just gotten some.

Go here:
Nhale Exhale Liquids - NHaler

And suggest trying the Nuport, Menthol 555 in 24mg although the last only on earlier raves about it in the older 'menthol thread'. I just ordered the Menthol 555 and a bunch of other stuff there after being impressed with the last order.

I've tried the menthol crystals and that does work but there is something special about the Nuport. I've tried about 9 different menthols now from various places and the Nuport from Nhaler and the "Newport" from freshsmoking are unique and good for my tastes anyway.
 

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California
EZ,

Sorry I should have been more specific. Nhaler/Drew - see the suppliers forum - has mostly 24mg juice. I just grabbed that link because I had just gotten some.

Go here:
Nhale Exhale Liquids - NHaler

And suggest trying the Nuport, Menthol 555 in 24mg although the last only on earlier raves about it in the older 'menthol thread'. I just ordered the Menthol 555 and a bunch of other stuff there after being impressed with the last order.

I've tried the menthol crystals and that does work but there is something special about the Nuport. I've tried about 9 different menthols now from various places and the Nuport from Nhaler and the "Newport" from freshsmoking are unique and good for my tastes anyway.

Hehe. It's kind of funny. I put an order in a few hours ago at Nhaler. I thought I had seen a 24mg Nuport flavor somewhere so I looked thru the juice vendors I bookmarked, and quickly found it. I was just checking my email to see if I got the order confirmation yet, and noticed an email notification to this thread.
Anyway, I got some Nuport (obviously), and a few samples of other flavors. Really hoping it is at least as good as the vermont vapor menthol. Will let you guys know what I think when it gets here. I'm guessing Monday at the latest.

Thanks for the info Kent, and for that matter. Thanks to everyone here who gave me some input.

Ez :)
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
Hehe. It's kind of funny. I put an order in a few hours ago at Nhaler. I thought I had seen a 24mg Nuport flavor somewhere so I looked thru the juice vendors I bookmarked, and quickly found it. I was just checking my email to see if I got the order confirmation yet, and noticed an email notification to this thread.
Anyway, I got some Nuport (obviously), and a few samples of other flavors. Really hoping it is at least as good as the vermont vapor menthol. Will let you guys know what I think when it gets here. I'm guessing Monday at the latest.

Thanks for the info Kent, and for that matter. Thanks to everyone here who gave me some input.

Ez :)

I've been meaning to check vermont vapors but they were having some problems last time... probably ok now. I just got an order from Decadent Vapours in England. Wow. Really Different (capital D) and good. Some just interesting but all good. Their MenthoEucalytus has to be kept in an air tight container - that could be a cold remedy! You know the point where you can smell or taste anything? This would solve that problem. lol. The Absinthe and Habana Reserve are my favorites with Absinthe a possible for breaking into my RY4, Cappucino, New/Nuport, TC, first string. I'll wait a few more days but it is "non sweet" - the thread in which I picked up the link - and very tasty. I don't know what the actual real product tastes like so can't judge that part. The Roast Beef really does taste and smell like roast beef to me. But a little goes a long way - again to sweet to that either. Black currant is third favorite and that won't be going in a drawer anytime soon.

They're also shut down in a deal with TW but when they get back up, if you're 'tasting all menthols' that menthoeucalytus should be on your list..... you may be able to get it from TW and miss the UK shipping....

Glad I could help and I too thank those in the other menthol thread for mentioning Nuport.
 

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California
Nhaler juice arrived this past Monday as expected. Vaping some of the peach blast right now.
Sadly though their nuport flavor wasn't what I had hoped it would be. It has a fairly strong tobacco base. I guess that's not what I'm looking for.
So far, for me, the Vermont Vapor menthol is the only one that doesn't have that tobacco taste mixed in. It's just a really smooth menthol flavor. Not like some kind of mint, or toothpaste, like some of the other menthols I've tried. But just a clean fresh menthol. Definitely my daily vape of choice so far, with their choco mint a close second.
But in my search for the best menthol, I'm starting to accumulate a lot of menthol juice that I really don't care for. So I think I will get some crystals, and make up the menthol drops listed in father lukes post. Hopefully, adding some of that to ones I don't care for, will turn them into a menthol juice I like.
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
Nhaler juice arrived this past Monday as expected. Vaping some of the peach blast right now.
Sadly though their nuport flavor wasn't what I had hoped it would be. It has a fairly strong tobacco base. I guess that's not what I'm looking for.
So far, for me, the Vermont Vapor menthol is the only one that doesn't have that tobacco taste mixed in. It's just a really smooth menthol flavor. Not like some kind of mint, or toothpaste, like some of the other menthols I've tried. But just a clean fresh menthol. Definitely my daily vape of choice so far, with their choco mint a close second.
But in my search for the best menthol, I'm starting to accumulate a lot of menthol juice that I really don't care for. So I think I will get some crystals, and make up the menthol drops listed in father lukes post. Hopefully, adding some of that to ones I don't care for, will turn them into a menthol juice I like.

Ok. For menthol no tobacco, Janty's, the Widow's "high" nic (although there was a question on that on another thread - someone claims to have gotten a mint in lower (med.) nic level... ) and freshsmoking 'deluxe' juice is menthol no tobacco. But if you like Vermont Vapors you should probably stick with that or if you're getting other stuff from those mentioned throw in a 10ml bottle on an order. That a good way to sample. Surprised you didn't like Nuport if you were a menthol smoker... oh well... to the classifieds on some of that stuff....
 

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California
Ok. For menthol no tobacco, Janty's, the Widow's "high" nic (although there was a question on that on another thread - someone claims to have gotten a mint in lower (med.) nic level... ) and freshsmoking 'deluxe' juice is menthol no tobacco. But if you like Vermont Vapors you should probably stick with that or if you're getting other stuff from those mentioned throw in a 10ml bottle on an order. That a good way to sample. Surprised you didn't like Nuport if you were a menthol smoker... oh well... to the classifieds on some of that stuff....

Tried the widows menthol but it was the Ex Hi nic, and it was tobacco based.
Haven't tried freshsmoking yet, but their deluxe juice is only 16mg, and I'm looking for at least 20. Do you know anything about their classic menthol? Because I did notice they have that in 24mg and even 36mg. Maybe I'll give that a shot, and get some menthol crystals at the same time.
 

Kent C

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 12, 2009
26,547
60,051
NW Ohio US
Tried the widows menthol but it was the Ex Hi nic, and it was tobacco based.

I'm surprised. I have the high and it's straight menthol. But maybe a different batch.

Haven't tried freshsmoking yet, but their deluxe juice is only 16mg, and I'm looking for at least 20.

Yep. 16mg

Do you know anything about their classic menthol?

Don't know. You might drop an email to them.

Because I did notice they have that in 24mg and even 36mg. Maybe I'll give that a shot, and get some menthol crystals at the same time

Menthol crystals, which I think was in my first link ;-) is the most surest way to avoid either tobacco or mints. And they have a 'tip' on how to do it there. It works. I tried it. Just in case you missed it, their 'Newport' is also tobacco based.
 
Last edited:

Ez Duzit

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 16, 2009
731
17
Southern California

UPDATE-

Thank you for this Father Luke - I finally got around to getting some menthol crystals and OMG. Amazing what a few drops of that mix can do. It is potent enough that only 2-3 drops per ml, in any of the tobacco based menthol juice I bought, almost completely covers up the tobacco flavor. Since I have almost 80ml of menthol juice I didn't really like. Once I add some drops to those, I'll have enough menthol to last me good while. At least a few days.:shock:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread