Looking for recommendations for a reliable tank system

Status
Not open for further replies.

neptoon

Full Member
Apr 18, 2013
43
2
Miami
I started vaping 2 months ago. Started with a vivi nova and didn't like it at all. I binned it. Bought an aga t2 and been vaping on that for the past month and found its also unreliable. I'm looking for a tank system that is the most reliable.

1. carto tank or protank?
2. Is there a carto tank with a glass tube, fill hole and a locking system for under 25-20 dollars?
3. Which provides more flavor protank or carto tanks?
 

ghost62

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
May 31, 2012
225
246
Marion, Ohio
IBTanked sells some really good pyrex tank kits, but no fill hole and no lock.
So far that hasn't been an issue because the quality and durability far outweigh any perceived shortcomings. They come with a filling tool, a priming tool and extra o-rings.
If you are dead set on the lock and fill hole, PM me and I will send you a link to a supplier (won't mention them by name as they aren't an ECF registered supplier) that sells tanks that meet every one of your criteria for under $10.00. I bought two of them because of the price. Decent enough tanks, but I still love my IBT's
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
I'll second the IBTanks as a high quality yet inexpensive glass cartotank. I currently own cartotanks from several different manufacturers http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/members/baditude-albums-pictures-my-setup.html and those are my favorites (I currently own seven and will be ordering more soon.).

I've done a review of the IBTanks here: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/blogs/baditude/3318-3-ibtanked-pyrex-glass-tanks-review.html

You'll get options on tank diameter, tank length, stainless steel or anodized aluminum caps (some in custom colors), colored o-rings, painted tube colors and designs, etc. No other tank vendor offers this variety.

http://www.ibtanked.com/

I've never understood the allure of a locking tank. I've used cartotanks for over a year and never had one slide off a carto nor leak. I carry my APV in a jeans pocket all the time with no concern of a possible mishap. A quality tank with proper fitting o-rings is not going to fall off of your battery device.

I've also not been attracted to purchasing a tank with a juice fill hole. This necessitates having a needle and syringe to fill the tank. I never liked the looks of that screw sticking out of the tank. Also, I'm the type of person who manages to lose small things like fill hole screws. When I use a tank accessory tool such as the Slap Yo Moma from Big Daddy Vapor, refilling a cartotank takes 30 seconds and is a breeze to accomplish.

Delrin SYM.jpg Slap Yo Moma tank accessory tool. A PBusardo Review - Slap Yo Mama Multi-Purpose Adapter - Big Daddy Vapor - YouTube
 
Last edited:

eratikmind

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 22, 2013
5,481
4,712
Las Vegas/San Francisco
I started vaping 2 months ago. Started with a vivi nova and didn't like it at all. I binned it. Bought an aga t2 and been vaping on that for the past month and found its also unreliable. I'm looking for a tank system that is the most reliable.

1. carto tank or protank?
2. Is there a carto tank with a glass tube, fill hole and a locking system for under 25-20 dollars?
3. Which provides more flavor protank or carto tanks?

I have 3 protanks and 11 cartotanks, thus far. As such, personally, I prefer a tank fitted with either a ikenvape cartomizer or a Diver from Atmistique.

Properly prepared, my cartotanks afford me a much better vaping experience. YMMV

- Andy

ETA: Oh, I would be remiss, if I did not add that 7 of the 11 tanks are OCD tanks from IBTanked . . . And a cartotank is only as good as the cartomizer, which you use. The tank simply stores the e-juice. Glass tubes are a must for me, personally.
 
Last edited:

neptoon

Full Member
Apr 18, 2013
43
2
Miami
I have 3 protanks and 11 cartotanks, thus far. As such, personally, I prefer a tank fitted with either a ikenvape cartomizer or a Diver from Atmistique.

Properly prepared, my cartotanks afford me a much better vaping experience. YMMV

- Andy

ETA: Oh, I would be remiss, if I did not add that 7 of the 11 tanks are OCD tanks from IBTanked . . . And a cartotank is only as good as the cartomizer, which you use. The tank simply stores the e-juice. Glass tubes are a must for me, personally.


So far nobody gave me straight answers to the 3 questions. I want to know which system delivers more reliability, flavor and vapor, cartos or protank.
I use a vamo with 50/50 white truffle juice. with an 18350 and sometimes 18650 battery.

About reliability I mean for example today I drove to the shop with my vamo fitted with aga t2 in my pocket. I take it out during the drive to puff and this always happens the coils must have moved and I taste a hotspot like always when i'm driving. Of course I need to take off the cap and fiddle with the damn coils during driving. I mean this is just ridiculous! this whole system sucks and i'm getting really tired of it.

Every little movement can wack the damn coils and u get a hotspot with ss mesh its so annoying!
 

KY_Rob

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 23, 2013
1,772
3,693
Kentucky
I started vaping 2 months ago. Started with a vivi nova and didn't like it at all. I binned it. Bought an aga t2 and been vaping on that for the past month and found its also unreliable. I'm looking for a tank system that is the most reliable.

1. carto tank or protank?
2. Is there a carto tank with a glass tube, fill hole and a locking system for under 25-20 dollars?
3. Which provides more flavor protank or carto tanks?

1) Both are reliable and perform well if using the proper tank & carto.
2) Artemis is an inexpensive locking tank (~$10). No fill hole, and its plastic, but I haven't had any issues with cracking/fogging/leaking. Don't know of anything like you're looking for in your price range.
3) I actually get better flavor from an IkenVape carto than a Protank, but its minimal difference. I use the Artemis locking tank with IkenVape carto's for my "all day vape", and Protanks when I'm out and about. My biggest complaint about the Protank is the small fluid capacity. Artemis hold 6ml.
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
So far nobody gave me straight answers to the 3 questions. I want to know which system delivers more reliability, flavor and vapor, cartos or protank.
I use a vamo with 50/50 white truffle juice. with an 18350 and sometimes 18650 battery.

About reliability I mean for example today I drove to the shop with my vamo fitted with aga t2 in my pocket. I take it out during the drive to puff and this always happens the coils must have moved and I taste a hotspot like always when i'm driving. Of course I need to take off the cap and fiddle with the damn coils during driving. I mean this is just ridiculous! this whole system sucks and i'm getting really tired of it.

Every little movement can wack the damn coils and u get a hotspot with ss mesh its so annoying!
I'll answer the best I can. I don't own a ProTank, but I have used plenty of other clearotanks. They use a similar string wick atomizer head; some are top coiled and some are bottom coiled. I found any of the top coiled string-wicked delivery devices to be a little on the fussy or "unreliable" side; you must frequently tip or swirl the device to keep the strings wet or you will get dry hits (which I find annoying). These often mute certain flavors, some to the point that the juice tastes like unflavored.

With the Protank being a bottom coiled tank, one would like to believe it would not be so position dependent as the top coiled tanks. But it is still dependent upon strings to wick juice to the heating coil. In contrast, a cartotank's heating coil is totally surrounded by polyfiller which bathes it in juice constantly.

My preferred delivery device for over a year has been pyrex cartotanks, more specifically the IBTanked. I have seven of the 19mm XL tanks, and just today ordered five more IBTanks in the 22mm XL size. How does that sound in terms to loyalty to a product you can depend upon?

I find cartotanks provide better flavor production. They are more consistant if you use a quality cartomizer. I too use Ikenvape carts. Cartotanks are not position dependent like the clearo devices are. A quality tank with proper fitting o-rings is not going to slip off the tank nor leak.

That's as specific as I can be, based on my honest experience. I'm sure you'll have someone say that they have had just the opposite experience of cartotank vs clearotank. Cartotanks do have a small learning curve, but if you follow a proven setup method you shouldn't have an issue with them. If you click the link under my avatar, you will find a series of blog articles, one of which is a step-by-step tutorial of the method I use successfully with my cartotanks.
___

FYI, I've had similar experience as you with my AGA T2 tanks. When they are working on all cylinders, there's not a better vape. But they are quite unpredictable and unreliable; they will leak when laid down on their side, and require a consistant backup delivery device. Mine happens to be pyrex cartotanks.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread