Okay, I vaped a few tank fulls and want to update my opinion a bit.
I have let Menthol X steep a few days and will give it quite a bit longer to breathe and settle. I feel like this one needs it with the "tobacco base" components, where as the other 4 menthols don't really change at all after a good steep.
The moth balls comparison (totally random, I know) has turned into sweet cotton candy. Exactly like the smell/taste of warm melted sugar. This flavor is very SWEET. Candy sweet. Cotton candy sweet.
I gave it a 7/10, which is a good score. It is extremely complex and original, unlike what you could throw together in a tank yourself. That's why I love Halo!
I might increase that to an 8/10. My only real beef is with the name/category, not the flavor. It's a misnomer. there's no frost. It should be called Tribeca X.
If this had twice the intriguing eucalyptus/peppermint than it does and was less sweet, it would be winner winner chicken dinner, for sure. The mixed mint tones are awesome! It's just unfortunate that they compose only ~20% of the flavor profile. With a name like Menthol X one might expect it to be at least half menthol.
Anyways... I hope my taste buds aren't too insane in the membrane. Please post your reviews when you get the chance to try Menthol X.