I'm also thinking now that my 510 PT might have shortened its own batt's life by overcharging it. In the beginning I was amazed at how much better the PT performed than the regular batts, and it could be that the batt was getting charged too high. I never checked it, and my PTs do not charge batts at all anymore.
I have a Bartleby on the way, which has USB charging capability and uses the 14500 batt. Actually I had it, but the charging LED didn't work, so Jay is replacing it. Will have to check how it charges. I do think the charging was working, as I would get overloading warnings on the laptop USB port when I plugged it in...and I never got those with a normal 510 PT, so it was certainly drawing more current. My electronic logic might not be correct here...I'm not so electro-savvy as some here. But while I would like USB charging, I don't want it to kill off the batts too quickly.