To clarify I believe my LA Red is from johnni?
Duplications of specific tobacco blends are one of the interesting developments we're seeing now, given the spread of retail NET liquids and the productivity of our small but growing band of intrepid home extractors. Both Johni and I have extracted
Hearth & Home Signature Louisiana Red Pipe tobacco. My extract is from a heat-assisted 80pg/20vg maceration (my typical warm water bath) with a short steep (one day), whereas Johni's is from a cold-process/room-temp long-steep all-PG maceration.
I now have
four different versions of
ACID Blondie---two retail juices (want2vape ACID Blondie, now called "The Blond" and RBFS Dagwood's Wife is Trippin') and two cold-process/room-temp home-extracts (Boomerdude's and Johni's). Although all four are made from the what are supposedly the very same cigars and share the idiosyncratic ACID Blondie flavor profile, meaningful differences in the overall vaping experience of those four juices/extracts are easily discernible, especially if they're vaped side-by-side.
I've extracted
American Spirit Organic cigarette/RYO blend, the same tobacco used in N-E-T.com's
Organic Spirit. Also, I've extracted
NAT Sherman MCD cigarettes, which are the same as N-E-T.com's
NS Dark or
NS Brown (I can't remember which---one is MCD and the other is Cigarillo, or so I assume).
And so it goes, multiple choices for the same tobacco blends. But then, that's commonplace in the eliquid marketplace. I've reviewed 160 different versions of RY4 over three years, and I'll bet a hundred more are available that I haven't vaped.