I've only tried two, Loranns to me was just sweet tasting and no peanut butter taste to it. PA is heavy on the peanut, but I thought it could use more creaminess to it. It was more like peanut's than peanut butter, it is also strong, so I guess you could try that and try adding something to give it a sweet creaminess to it.
I haven't had any luck finding the perfect peanut butter, but then think of all the different brands of real peanut butter that are out and they all taste different.