I haven't tried either of those, but I will thanks to your recommendation. Agree on CAP GP - it goes into mixes with other pineapples at under 1% to add sweetness.
Have you tried Inawera Pineapple? It is wonderful!
This is a fresh, juicy, authentic fresh pineapple flavor. It is juicy and sweet, like a fresh pineapple. It is weak for Inawera but a very good pineapple flavor. Use as high as 5% and maybe as high as 6 to 7%, even in a mix. This flavor is in a virtual tie with Vape Train’s Sugarloaf Pineapple for best pineapple flavor available. If I use it with just a touch of CAP in my Piña Colada, it goes in at 5.5%.
VT Sugarloaf is a real winner, IMO.
Sugarloaf pineapple is a pineapple variety that is white and even the core can be eaten. This is the Kauai Hawaiian pineapple and what you get if you get pineapple in Hawaii. The VT Sugarloaf Pineapple is a fresh, juicy, sweet, authentic pineapple. It is as good as Inawera’s pineapple and maybe even better, more authentic – I give it a slight edge over INW. It is sweet, it is juicy, it tastes as fresh as a bottled flavor can taste. Like other pineapple flavors, it is not strong. Use it at 5% to 6% in a mix. I mixed it half and half with INW in my latest Piña Colada experiment, 3% of each VT and INW.