I can't recommend anything that similar - I think you might like want2vape's juice... It always reminded me of Don's at BWB. Donnely from want2vape reminds me a bit of Don from BWB. They are both really passionate about juices and they are kind of perfectionists. Their nic and base are the same I believe. (they used to be anyway). They both used true top of the line... and didn't skimp on the pg/vg or nic. They also have some proprietary flavorings that no one else has on some of their juices. Lastly, they cost about the same.
Another company I'd recommend is Doodlebug. It's quite inexpensive and very good imo. The tobacco extracts are quite sweet, unless you get the acid blonde cigar... that's more like a cigarette. I get the Acid Blonde and the banana creme burley.
BWB will open up again soon.
It's a family business.
If someone is sick, goes down for a bit or if they take a well deserved vacation, we have to wait ;-)
Family comes first.
In any case, I do empathize. BWB has a handful of juices that have been irreplaceable staples for me also.