I make an apple pie 
juice that is pretty good.  8% apple extract, 4% cinnamon Danish, 80% VG, 12mg nic, taste like an apple pie tart.  If you used more cinnamon and added a dash of Virginia fired Tobacco, a bit of all spice, thinking this would get spiced apple. I will try the Fired tobacco on my next batch, thinking this will be good, and get back to you.  Thanks for the recipe change idea.  Love my DIY juice.