Update on my thesis research

Status
Not open for further replies.

B2L

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 14, 2012
7,844
45,313
Jacksonville, FL
Yeah, easy quick survey but I feel it needs someone who actually vaped for a while to help you ask the questions. There were too many questions with smoking/nicotine in it rather than vaping/nicotine. A few questions I had to put "I don't know" as the answer as I don't smoke anymore.

Just took the survey, hope the information you gather here is helpful. I agree with eebant, the question that stood out to me was "Do you believe using nicotine products have damaged your health?" (Or something close to that) While I feel that vaping has improved my health, 25+ years of smoking definitely had a negative effect.
 

MD_Boater

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Nov 6, 2013
583
1,020
Maryland Chesapeake Bay
Question: Do you believe that tobacco/nicotine products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?

It is the smoke that causes the major health problems, not the tobacco and not the nicotine.

I think this question needs to be made into 2 questions in order to get the information Kmel is after.

Do you believe that smoking tobacco products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?
Do you believe that using alternative nicotine products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
I think this question needs to be made into 2 questions in order to get the information Kmel is after.

Do you believe that smoking tobacco products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?
Do you believe that using alternative nicotine products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?

It's strange enough the question is about "do you believe".
And the original question does not have the word smoking in it either.
 
Question: What is your age?

It changes every year.

Question: What is your race?

What? Aren't we past that yet?

Human.

You are absolutely right, edyle! The terms we use to collect demographic data are outdated to saay the least. Unfortunately, most internal review boards still make you tuck a few of those questions into any reserach you do. Also, I am genuinely curious to know if there are any patterns among ECF users (not just vapers) and who knows - we may find that only one sort of vaper uses ECF (whether we gauge that by age or sex or race or whathaveyou), or we could find that ECF is a true microcosm of vapers around the world. I would also posit that, sadly, the US is still years behind the EU with most civil rights-related issues. Keep giving feedback though, to anyone willing to hear you out. Surely we will all catch up; and we will realize that, in any way that means anything, we are all alike. (I could go on, but I imagine you catch my meaning - I think you and I are on the same page about this stuff).
 
Question: Do you believe that tobacco/nicotine products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?

It is the smoke that causes the major health problems, not the tobacco and not the nicotine.

Another good point, edyle! In reflection, this question should have been split in two: one addressing tobacco and health, the other pertaining to nicotine and health. Two completely different thoughts, in spite of the fact that we are measuring perception - after all, a vapers preceptoin of tobacco is liekly vastly different than their thoughts about nicotine (otherwise, why ever give up smoking, right?) Terrific food for thought! I will make sur ethat future surveys recognize this dicotomy. :)
 
Just took the survey, hope the information you gather here is helpful. I agree with eebant, the question that stood out to me was "Do you believe using nicotine products have damaged your health?" (Or something close to that) While I feel that vaping has improved my health, 25+ years of smoking definitely had a negative effect.

Thank you for your participatoin and feedback, B2L! You and edyle are absolutely right; this question would have likely served our purpose better were it divided in two; one part addressing tobacco and the other addressing nicotine. Hindsight is always 20/20, but I am definitely making note of this for future revisions of this and similar research surveys. Thank you again - absolutely invaluable!! :)
 
I think this question needs to be made into 2 questions in order to get the information Kmel is after.

Do you believe that smoking tobacco products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?
Do you believe that using alternative nicotine products is causing or caused a health problem for you or made it worse?

You are absolutely right, MD_Boater; in hindsight, the quetsion would have better gotten at the data we are after were it put as two seperate questions: one addressing tobacco and the other pertaining to nicotine exclusively. Hindsight is always 20/20, but I am making note of this feedback for the eventual revisoin of this survey, as well as for future reserach I may do with regard to e-cigs. Thank you for your participation and feedback - both are extrememly helpful to me!! :)
 
Survey completed.

Terrific! Thank you again, edyle, for your participation and all of your valuable feedback. Thank goodness I can print out this thread, b/c you all are giving me so much info that is new to me it would be difficult to keep up with were it not for that luxury. If anything else occurs to you about the survey (or anything else you feel may be pertinent), please do reach out to me at your convenience! :)
 

edyle

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 23, 2013
14,199
7,195
Port-of-Spain, Trinidad & Tobago
Another good point, edyle! In reflection, this question should have been split in two: one addressing tobacco and health, the other pertaining to nicotine and health. Two completely different thoughts, in spite of the fact that we are measuring perception - after all, a vapers preceptoin of tobacco is liekly vastly different than their thoughts about nicotine (otherwise, why ever give up smoking, right?) Terrific food for thought! I will make sur ethat future surveys recognize this dicotomy. :)


Again: it sounds like a deliberate attempt to steer away from SMOKE and Health.

There is this constant emphasis that ecigs may constain tobacco products and or nicotine, but the actual problem with smoking has always been the SMOKE and what it does to the LUNGS.
 
Again: it sounds like a deliberate attempt to steer away from SMOKE and Health.

There is this constant emphasis that ecigs may constain tobacco products and or nicotine, but the actual problem with smoking has always been the SMOKE and what it does to the LUNGS.

I assure you, edyle, there is no conscious, deliberate attempt to steer away from smoke and health. Quite the contrary, I feel I have been glib, and would like to be sure I am being very clear - it is taken for granted in health circles that smoking is inextricably linked to bad health outcomes, almost without fail (in other words, if you smoke traditional/analog cigarettes, you will get sick eventually if something else doesn't kill you first). There is no evidence to indicate that nicotine in minute amounts is very bad for you at all, and compared to all the garbage in analog/traditional cigarettes, I would argue that e-cigs are down-right healthy, w/ or w/o nicotine!

I saw what analogs do in the long term second hand: my father had to have a triple bypass surgery after decades of smoking. So I am a bit biased. I am also a bit biased, however, b/c I began vaping about 3 yrs. ago, and have not smoked analogs since. This is part of why I felt e-cigarette use, and vaper's perceptions of their use of e-cigs, their past smoking (if any) and the inherent health problems that come with smoking are of interest to me. I am aware of the fact that there is no link between e-cigs and health problems, but I am very interested in seeing if other vapers are aware of that, and whether or not they fear some negative health outcomes (albeit, baseless fear, from what we know at this point). So please let me assure you, I am all for e-cigs, for me and for anyone like me - someone who tried darn near every other tactic to quit w/o success, and who would really like to avoid massive heart surgery and all of the other awful ramifications of smoking. I am confident that, w/o e-cigs, I would still be a smoker and in much worse shape because of it.

I hope that I did not offend you, either in my survey wording, or in my explanation above, but I want you to know, on a very personal level, that I am a supporter, and user, of e-cigs. And I am happy to say that, in the world of public health, I am not alone. Thank you again for your participation and feedback. If you have any additional ideas that you would like to share (I would especially like to know any advice you may have for me when I re-write this survey's questions as to how I can get at the info I have indicated above w/o coming off as disingenuous), or if you would just like to chat more about our respective experiences in vaping, health, etc., please let me know it! :)
 
Last edited:
Thank you to all of you who have responded to my request for assistance with my reserach! I apologize if I missed thanking any of you personally. If you have not yet taken a look at my reserach document and would like to, please send me a PM at your convenience - I will be sure to follow up with you w/n 24 hours. Thank yuo again for all of your help!!
 
I have had terrific turn out for help with my research (thank you again to all who've participated thus far)! I could, however, still use your assistance! If you have not yet assisted me and would like to do so, please send me a PM and I will provide you with more info. And again, my sincere thanks for your participation and for my warm welcome to ECF! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread