Like a couple people have said, it's going to be very difficult to replicate an actual cigarette flavor without the actual burning of tobacco (and the thousands of chemical additives in analogs). It's the same principle as chocolate, without using something derived from cacao. It's not an issue exclusive to V4L, it's just the nature of e-liquid. Multiply that by the number of variances in desire that each person has, and well...you get the idea.
What I've found to satisfy the "feel" of smoking an analog is stuff like the Caramel Mocha Frappucino 24mg. It gives the 'full mouth hit' that I crave in the mornings. I think it's a combination of the 24mg nic strength (some even go up to 36mg) but also the coffee base that seems to replicate the mouth- and throat-feel of smoking.
Does it taste like the Marlboro's I smoked exclusively for 15 years? No, thank God.

Heh, even after 3 short weeks of vaping, walking by or standing in the smoking area at work sometimes makes me wince. But CMF acts as the placebo for the
experience I got from lighting up an analog.
The point is, it might take some experimenting with various flavors, nic strengths, and vendors to find what satisfies your smoking demon. I feel confident in the hardware I have now (from V4L), so the search continues for me in finding my 5 go-to flavors. I have no less than 40 bottles of liquid (some VG and some PG) from 5 vendors and another 2 orders coming in this week. I dont want to make it sound like vaping is this huge daunting task, the experimenting is even a little fun. But I'm committed to not going back to analogs, so I'll do some leg-work and spend some $$ up front, to ensure I find exactly what it's gonna take to keep my commitment.
So apart from CMF, you might want to try another of the coffee-based flavors. The Butterscotch cartos might also work, I'm looking forward to those myself. And of course there is VG liquid, which will come closer to the fullness of real smoke, but will be a little lighter on the throat.
Good luck finding your favorites, and Happy Vaping...