VG Menthol from GoodProphets

[Crystallas]

I have been in search for that perfect menthol e-liquid for close to a year now. I may have ordered close to 20 different menthols to vape by now, and my conclusion is....

There is no perfect menthol! Nothing that I have tried comes close to any Menthol Analog that I smoked in the past.

But what I do think I have found here, is a new friend. And that is the VG Menthol from GoodProphets. It's versatile, and that's why I like it. This is the first menthol that I can vape on all-day, and not think about all of the old flavors that I used to smoke. I can drip this in with a tobacco flavor, and the tobacco flavor wont turn into a nutty ashtray with a hint of mint(if you get what I mean.)

Vapor: 4.5/5
Throat Hit: 5/5
Minty-scale: I would best describe this as Listerine Cool Mint, without the taste of the antiseptic.

Right now, this is my new standard for menthol. I vape a ton of different flavors and I was only a casual menthol smoker before I quit, I smoked all different brands of cigarettes, and I liked to change it up a bit. But this specific menthol was the first to give me a full-on impression of being a menthol flavor, and I really don't see myself ordering any more to try at this point.

I also love GoodProphets right now. They are in my top 5 fav Vape-stores. I can highly recommend them. The VG is amazing, the USA-Made flavors are average and I wouldn't recommend those over others, but all of the VG flavors that I have tried are among the best that I have vaped.

VG E-Liquid @ Goodprophets

 

[Crystallas]

So far I'm close to 2 weeks on this GP VG Menthol. I ordered a spare battery from EastMall and picked up some of their Menthol because it was one of the few I didn't try yet. It's decent, and maybe the EM Menthol needs to sit for a week or so before it really shows off, but it's just not as good, in a long list of disappointing menthols.

I really would like to get a spreadsheet type of deal on every Menthol I have tried up to this point. Anyone have something along these lines yet? I know when searching, there are a few menthol smokers here that have the same hit-or-miss.

 

[Jimi Mack]

If you are looking for a list of most suppliers for juice try this...

E-Liquid Cost-per-ml | Socrata | Making Data Social

It should at least remind you of most of the dealers you have tied, if anything it may show you some you have not.

For me, I have happiest with the menthol from Tasty Vapor and I order some of their Vanilla Custard and add about 20% to the menthol, this has been my go to daily vape.

 

[proudlion]

Crystallas - I'm also almost exclusively a Menthol person and have ordered from just about every supplier in ECF - since taste is so subjective it is difficult to suggest what someone else might like.

Jimi Mack - thank you so much for that link!

 

[Crystallas]

Crystallas - I'm also almost exclusively a Menthol person and have ordered from just about every supplier in ECF - since taste is so subjective it is difficult to suggest what someone else might like.

Taste is subjective. But whats the point of this forum section? Whats your take on this new VG from GP then?