Good morning. I placed an order on Cyber Monday (#1129248) and I also only got a 4% VIP discount (I also used the CyberMonday code). I noticed it at the time, but didn't bother asking--I guess that I should have said something. Looking at the invoice in my account, it doesn't list the percentage, but the "newsletter discount" is only 4% of what I paid. Since it wasn't a big order, it's not a big deal, but I did want to point out that cainam wasn't alone.