Has anyone tried both the whiskey and the cognac? How do they compare? To my surprise, I love the whiskey. I also liked the RY4 carts. I thought they tasted very similar to the whiskey. I ordered a bottle of the RY4 juice but it tastes differently than the carts did. It has a minty flavor now which the carts did not have. I still like it though. Anyway, any info you can give would be appreciated. Thanks!
Whiskey vs Cognac vs RY4
- Thread starter klobdob
- Start date
- th_trl_thread_readers 0
- Status
I haven't tried the whiskey.
I got a cognac in my last order and I'm not a fan. It tastes OK for 5 or 6 draws, then I want something else.
Bob
I got a cognac in my last order and I'm not a fan. It tastes OK for 5 or 6 draws, then I want something else.
Bob
I have tried both. I like the Whiskey but not the Cognac. The whiskey has a subtle sweetness that I really enjoy. It will go nicely with my Wild Turkey American Honey this winter. Very smooth.
Thank you all for your posts. I really appreciate it. Just ordered a ton more whiskey. It is funny really. I was talking about not being able to wait to get more whiskey. My daughter gave me such a strange look that I had to clarify that it was not REAL whiskey, lol.
I actually liked the cognac. good flavor. not too sweet, it really came alive on my pass through for some reason.
I Love whiskey, Cognac, not so much. I can't really place it, but I think maybe it's fruity(?). Either way, Whiskey is one of my go-to's, I won't be ordering Cognac again. FWIW, I don't like RY4 either.
I have never tried the wiskey but i got a sample of the cognac and all i have to say is i thought it had an amazing taste a lot of vapor and like modestmark said on the passthrough it woke up in an amazing way... this is a 10 in my book.
Great! Now I have to order some cognac too, lol. But who am I kidding, I'd be placing another order the same day I get the last one anyway. I had read on here that the V4L flavors are superior, but even still I really thought that I would switch to the VK, order a couple packs of carts and just refill, refill, refill. About 20 packs of carts later...... and it has only been a few weeks! I have refilled some though. Now I am starting to just buy juice from V4L so I can have the same great flavors. I feel bad though, I had already collected so much DIY stuff. I guess I will be set if there is ever a ban.
I think when they went to find a bottle of cognac to base the flavor on, they mistakenly got B&B instead. That's what it tastes like to me, and the orange isn't right somehow. Glad others like it though; that's why there's more than one flavor out there. 
I'm with Mark and Mark, the cognac is verrry nice indeed. It's a bit of a champagne grape taste IMO, with subtle woody/smokey on the exhale. In fact, anyone looking for a wine flavor would probably enjoy the cognac greatly. Ahhhh wow it's hitting me how much taste bud improvement I'm seeing as the days go by with no analogs! But still apparently not good enough to appreciate the green tea, I'm not getting much of any flavor from that one. Awesome throat hit though, and great vapor too. It's just subtle in the flavor department, at least for where I'm at. Of course, I couldn't taste anything hardly just a week or two ago so that will likely change.
I'm in to try the whiskey too, next order. And I LOVE RY4, although just a touch more caramel flavor would totally make the flavor for me.
I'm in to try the whiskey too, next order. And I LOVE RY4, although just a touch more caramel flavor would totally make the flavor for me.
They sent me a cognac, and I really didn't care for it. I think I had a good 10 puffs on it before I threw it in the refill bin.
I liked the whiskey, haven't tried the cognac.. Im a fan of cognac itself, the cognac cartomizers are the next on my list to order along with a few others i haven't tried yet but can't wait to try
I'm really picky on Cognac, and so I bet that was part of the reason I didn't care for it.
Cognac? 8-o That is definately not my thing. I love the beer though! Might have to give the whisky a try if it isn't like the cognac!
- Status
Similar threads
