Youtube...who do you trust

Status
Not open for further replies.

Equality 7-2521

Moved On
ECF Veteran
Jan 29, 2013
1,056
2,071
oakland ca.
Ya know, I swear I was going to say the same thing. Tough understand but, what bothered me most is he comes off extremely indecisive. Never a concise, definitive conclusion. I think any of these guys should have their opinions set before they do a review. Any of them. Todd looks around in wonder about everything he is about to say. I know some people like 'him' but I wonder if most are Brits and have no issues with his clarity? Let me be CLEAR, it is NOT personal or, based on UK or USA. How shallow I would be. He seems like a charming guy but, my op asked about reviewing trust. I don't care pretty, or charming or, funny some one is if they're just shills for their vendor, right? I would like to know two things up front from any reviewer, did you pay for what you're about to review and, how many days or weeks have you 'tested' or 'played' with it.
A 30 minute review from someone who you are watching open a box and try? Really? I don't particularly care for "My first impression" reviews. Your first impression?? Are you going to come back in thirty days for a follow up?? Of course, there I go again, LOL. I think a reviewer has a responsibility to do a follow up on EVERY product, if his opinions have changed. I don't see much of that :( Whew! I'm exhausted! I need a ciggar%#*, I mean vape!
I gotta say, I'm happy this * page thread has not turned into any kind of hate or bash fest :) :)

I think you've mistaken diplomacy for indecision. imagine saying in a frank brutal way you think some attys is crap....great wonderful, or that the golden greek is a crap company......imagine the planeloads of nasty emails you'd get from people who disagree with you...who needs the hassle....fools rush in where wise men dare not tread.So I think he couches things in such a way as to not invite undue ire, but in clear enough terms for most people to get.as for the two things you want to know.Todds really upfront about both those things it's usually the first things out of his mouth when doing a review.
 

FACE MEAT

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Mar 1, 2013
2,276
4,815
45
Costa Mesa, CA
At the top of my podium are both Todd and Phil. They're equally honest and entertaining. I really appreciate the frequency with which Mr. Todd uploads. I also really like they way he says "knurling".

My absolute least favorite has for to be Dimitris. There's something about him that rubs me the wrong way. I'm sure he's a nice enough guy and he's done some good things for vaping. However, I can't help but cringe whenever I come across his videos.
 

ImageX

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 26, 2013
157
147
US
Among others, I watch BPusardo, Rip Tripper, Grimm, Vapin' Greek, Todd's, and Indoor Smokers. The latter is way "out there" sometimes but I think that's why people watch. lol His reviews and info is tailored towards newbies and cheap gear from China, getting free stuff for himself, and getting free stuff to do giveaways in order to attract subscribers. He practically begs for subscribers sometimes. He's more motivated to gain subscribers($$$)than actually helping the community.

I know many like Todd's e-cig reviews but I just can't stand his pauses when he gets that stupid half grin on his face and just stares off into space for a while.

I have a difficult time watching his videos anymore. He gives good trusted info and is good overall but his delivery is WAAAAY too slow. I often lose patience with his style and just move on to other videos. Guys like Rip Tripper are the best for me. Good info, straight to the point, and without losing focus or pace.
 
Last edited:

FRANKSTER

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Oct 13, 2011
854
320
71
staten island, new york
I had to look her up.

How to put your makeup on when you're drunk, Drunk Hair tutorial, etc. --- (F word every other word interspersed w/other swear words)

THIS is the role model for young teenage girls these days w/the most YouTube hits?

God help us. She makes Paris Hilton look like a Ph.D. :)
Hope she invests the $$ well, cuz I don't see much future there. :lol:

I also looked up jenna marbles...Personally, I don't care what she has to say, but does anyone have her phone number...I would love to take her out for a drink. That is one good-looking girl and that is all I care about...lol
 

Conchord George

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 11, 2013
167
110
NH
I will usually only watch them if I'm looking for information on a specific product.

I bought a Micro Stick based on Scott's review.
I like Todd's vids because he seems very upfront and trustworthy as well.
Vapin Greek because we're fellow Greeks!

pbusardo has some negative things to consider.
He is so popular that he get's things directly from the manufacturer. That's like a food critic going in to a restaurant and saying "I'm the food critic here to review your food!" He raved on and on about the Aspire stuff he was sent direct. Many other people have been having problems.
Plus... doesn't he work for Provape? He definitely has in the past.
Not saying he has bad intentions. I think it's probably the opposite.
 

Mark Todd

Reviewer / Blogger
ECF Veteran
  • Apr 4, 2012
    450
    2,918
    56
    Fife, Scotland
    www.toddsreviews.com
    I was just going to get back to my movie but, I have to ask??? Is it not 'hip' to like BDC's. I know diddly about the subject. I just made sure I bought that type because not knowing, I feared I'd have to tip all the time??!!

    You're cool mate! I hope you are OK with some of the criticisms made? Maybe they will even be useful :)

    I only say that as a lot of comments I get are that I only review high end gear and that I'm elitist ;)

    Criticisms, never pay much attention to them now, constructive feedback, now that I like :D

    Pauses, grins, rambles, that's who I am, I'm like that in real life and not just going to change my character for reviewing ecigs LOL
     

    emus

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Jun 9, 2009
    4,804
    2,007
    I only say that as a lot of comments I get are that I only review high end gear and that I'm elitist ;)

    Criticisms, never pay much attention to them now, constructive feedback, now that I like :D

    Pauses, grins, rambles, that's who I am, I'm like that in real life and not just going to change my character for reviewing ecigs LOL

    Thank's for taking the time to review so many devices. Very helpful. You do a fine job considering the production budget!
     

    JMarca

    E-Cig Afficionado
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Mar 19, 2013
    1,522
    1,987
    47
    New York
    I would say there is a reason why all ask you to Subscribe and follow/stalk/whatever. There are youtuber's like a Jenna Marbles who I'm sure makes into the 10's of thousands yearly. Each one of her weekly videos get a million++ views. Not saying any vape reviewer is in her league. Of course she's on the high end. Then there are folks like me who got a 200.00 check for 1 video.
    No one is going to tell how much they receive.

    It gets worse, I've personally (in person) seen a high profile reviewer take a product to review with a little cash on the side at a vape meet. A week later it got a positive review on the web. Was it really good? Dunno.

    I know alot of things happen under the table with some people though, I'm not going to give any names I'm not throwing myself under the bus lots of people here love em'. Todd it's not you mate, we don't even live in the same country, I do watch your hardware reviews though.

    I don't watch these YouTube videos to make a decision whether to buy or not, I more so watch them just to see what's out there, most of the stuff I'd never buy anyway.

    My favorite list (mind you my list is based on more technical vapors):

    JCWest
    RIP Trippers
    Todd's Reviews
    BishopHeals

    If I'm going to watch something I don't want to sit there and watch you vape it and tell me your story about it, rip it apart and put it back together.
     
    Last edited:

    FRANKSTER

    Super Member
    ECF Veteran
    Oct 13, 2011
    854
    320
    71
    staten island, new york
    It gets worse, I've personally (in person) seen a high profile reviewer take a product to review with a little cash on the side at a vape meet. A week later it got a positive review on the web. Was it really good? Dunno.

    I know alot of things happen under the table with some people though, I'm not going to give any names I'm not throwing myself under the bus lots of people here love em'. Todd it's not you mate, we don't even live in the same country, I do watch your hardware reviews though.

    I don't watch these YouTube videos to make a decision whether to buy or not, I more so watch them just to see what's out there, most of the stuff I'd never buy anyway.

    My favorite list (mind you my list is based on more technical vapors):

    JCWest
    RIP Trippers
    Todd's Reviews
    BishopHeals

    If I'm going to watch something I don't want to sit there and watch you vape it and tell me your story about it, rip it apart and put it back together.
    I agree with your statement and I am beginning to think these reviewers are all shills. You should name the person...so what if you take the heat. The truth is the truth and these people should be exposed. I got your back no matter who it is. Even if it is my favorite reviewer...vapers should stick together not with the vendors...I think it is getting totally out of hand.
     

    Hatren

    Full Member
    Nov 23, 2013
    25
    48
    United States
    I had to look her up.

    How to put your makeup on when you're drunk, Drunk Hair tutorial, etc. --- (F word every other word interspersed w/other swear words)

    THIS is the role model for young teenage girls these days w/the most YouTube hits?

    God help us. She makes Paris Hilton look like a Ph.D. :)
    Hope she invests the $$ well, cuz I don't see much future there. :lol:

    Just so you know, her channel is meant for comedy, so her videos are purely satirical:)

    I really enjoy RIPTrippers, Vapingwithtwisted420, GrimmGreen, and Pbusardo, but I'm definitely check out Todd since everyone raves about him so much:)
     

    Equality 7-2521

    Moved On
    ECF Veteran
    Jan 29, 2013
    1,056
    2,071
    oakland ca.
    Oh. yeah BisopHeals what a great resource, great and innovative vaper
    It gets worse, I've personally (in person) seen a high profile reviewer take a product to review with a little cash on the side at a vape meet. A week later it got a positive review on the web. Was it really good? Dunno.

    I know alot of things happen under the table with some people though, I'm not going to give any names I'm not throwing myself under the bus lots of people here love em'. Todd it's not you mate, we don't even live in the same country, I do watch your hardware reviews though.

    I don't watch these YouTube videos to make a decision whether to buy or not, I more so watch them just to see what's out there, most of the stuff I'd never buy anyway.

    My favorite list (mind you my list is based on more technical vapors):

    JCWest
    RIP Trippers
    Todd's Reviews
    BishopHeals

    If I'm going to watch something I don't want to sit there and watch you vape it and tell me your story about it, rip it apart and put it back together.
     

    DavidAmonettNashville

    Ultra Member
    ECF Veteran
    Jan 2, 2014
    1,484
    2,972
    Nashville,Tn
    P. Busardo is the only reviewer I ever saw come right out and call something a piece of junk. I think it's a toss-up on who does the best instructional reviews, Phil or Todd, both are great when it comes to showing how it's done. Vape Girl is the great philosopher of the vaping world IMHO.

    I am subscribed to Vape girl too but lately her videos have become more risqué....On her Halloween episode the caption was asking "Is this outfit too Slu**y?" My wife just so happened to see my feed and I had to take her through Vape girls older videos to show her that the girl was in fact a reviewer and nothing more....I don't need that type drama even if it does drive her views up Cause when Mamas not happy nobody's happy...
     

    Equality 7-2521

    Moved On
    ECF Veteran
    Jan 29, 2013
    1,056
    2,071
    oakland ca.
    i gotta say i find Scotts reviews useless every time he reviews a genny he always says the same thing.........."flavors great..like what you'd expect from a gennis style atomizer'.

    whereas todd will relate it to similar attys, or say it's got better flavor than that atty or produces great vapor like so and so atty. or has better flavor than most gennys
     

    vapdivrr

    Vaping Master
    ECF Veteran
    Verified Member
    Jul 8, 2012
    9,966
    19,933
    61
    sarasota,fl
    But I'm thinking about you and all the wonderful things you say about me, I'll try to restrain myself in future and think of Nuns and Baseball instead ;)

    I have to agree with the above post, I do enjoy the info but I find myself speeding up the video, bypassing the long pauses of nothingness smiles.
     
    Status
    Not open for further replies.

    Users who are viewing this thread