Smell: 10/10 Has a very pleasant smell. Both the apple and caramel are evident. Vapor: 10/10 My mix is 80/20 @ 24mg. Plenty of vapor, no complaints here. Throat Hit: 9/10 YMMV - Mine is an 80/20 mix @24mg. So depending on your MG of choice TH may differ, in which case you could compensate with your VG% if you really want. I personally am a mouth inhaler, so I like that kick (which is great at my mix) when finally taking it into the lungs; so I'm not entirely sure how my opinion may translate with lung inhalers. Taste: 9/10 Reasoning for the 9 is because my initial impression of it was great. I could taste the apple tart in the Granny Smith (kind of reminds me of Loranns Apple) On a few draws I did get a kind of chemical apple taste thing going on, however I've noticed that any flavors that tend to have a chemical-like taste initially tend to go away after its aged a bit. (prolly give it a 10/10 after some aging) The caramel flavor is definitely there and I enjoy this Caramel Apple combination much more than the original TV Caramel apple (w/Red Apple flavoring) After a week I'm sure it will be amazing, but even as I write this its pretty damn close to what I was hoping for when wanting a Green Apple base. +1 to TV for bringing the Granny Smith flavoring. I don't do many reviews so I apologize if I left anything out. I'm very happy with this liquid and am gonna put my original TV Caramel Apple up for the swap thread, since this is the one I've been waiting for and am not the least bit disappointed.