Trayce, Not sure I can help you with what you're looking for because I haven't smoked either of the two you mention but I can say that VR juices all taste the same. It's the same artibacco (IMO) with different flavorings added. If you like one, you'll like them all. If you don't like one, you wont like any of them. Sounds like you'd be wasting your time paddling down the Vermillion River.
Oh def so and I never went back. Not that they have bad juice, everyone's taste buds are different, but it amazes me that that tastes like tobacco to some, and that no one mentioned "nutty flavor" in any the the reviews I read at the time.
But based on your preferences, I assume you will like sweeter vapes. Try Heather' Heavenly Vapes (Dragon's Fire, Heavenly Tobacco, Heavenly Army, Shadow, Legend, Serendipity). Also, it would seem you might like RY4's. There are lots of RY4 aficionados on this thread (esp BillH). Look back several pages and he links you to all his RY4 research. There is tons of it.
I love RY4, thanks. But wanted to add a Captain Black (or Black & Milk) juice to my meager lineup. Little more pipe-tasting than RY4. (Dad always smoked Captain Black when I was a kid and loved that smell.) I also smoked Black & Milds for awhile occasionally and really liked those.
I might just pick up some Cpt Black and a box of B&Ms and try extracting my own... I have a recipe from another thread in the DIY section. But I guess I'm looking for the easy, lazy way out, if a good ejuice is already out there of this type. I know the original Seedman's Cpt Black was supposed to be really good, but people said they reformulated a couple years back and it's way different. (And one person used the work NUT so that's out!)