PureCig with Menthol is nice, but don't expect it to be like a Salem Light.
A lot of people new to vaping expect to find something that is just like what they used to smoke and its more than likely not going to exist. But then too, your not getting all the chemicals and everything else they put into cigarettes to make you like them.
Try ordering small sample bottles of flavors you think you might like, French Toast, HopScotch, Wyatt Earp and Hypnotic Mist seem to all be well liked. Might be a good starting place. If your more interested in tobacco types of juice, FSUSA has a big selection of those, but again, start with little sample bottles until you find out what you like.