Beta Carboline MAOIs - towards a more effective e-liquid (Cont)

Status
Not open for further replies.

LJ17

New Member
Feb 22, 2021
3
3
Hi I wanted to see if I could continue this old thread.
<LINKS to cigarettes and MAO inhibition being critical in tobacco dependence is listed at bottom of post >
I am using whole tobacco alkaloid 3mg nicotine e juice at the moment and wondered if anyone else does. Also wanted to see if we can continue the discussion.
Here is a link to old thread : Beta Carboline MAOIs - towards a more effective e-liquid
All I see is it is closed to replies and haven’t found any other recent threads/posts for it.
But I have been vaping nicotine and find it ineffective in quitting cigs. Smoking and vaping felt totally different, nicotine alone (even 3mg per ml juice) gives me quite a bit of anxiety. I tried to increase to 6mg and so on, and the anxiety gets even worse the higher I go. I still vape anyways but hate the anxiety. Cigs don’t give me anxiety, in fact they often calm me while also being stimulating. Many times after a cigarette I have no anxiety left, so it reduces anxiety. Yet vaping literally gives me anxiety. Also I noticed increased depression when trying vape only (due to lack of MAOIs and other tobacco alkaloids) So yeah I knew something was missing/wrong and I researched WTA.
I bought some WTA 3mg liquid a while ago, but am just truly trying them out daily starting today. They aren’t even close to expired and juice taste fine. I am going to try to vape ONLY WTA e liquid stating today, and try not to smoke any cigarettes at all.

Here is what my juice contains:

Nicotine (3mg per ML) , Nornicotine, Anabasine, Anatabine

Unfortunately I cannot find any liquid that contains harman and norharman, which are known to be sufficiently potent MAO inhibitors. I believe those are the only two things missing to make this nicotine juice work perfectly to get me fully off cigarettes.
Does anyone know if Nornicotine, Anabasine, Anatabine has MAO inhibitor actions? Google doesn’t seem to help. I read a couple of patents (or applied for patents) that mention them working as MAO inhibitors, but that’s all. I can add link later if anyone interested.
I would post more details but want to make sure it’s okay to continue that old topic first so I don’t waste anymore time typing lol.

“Nicotine is the major neuroactive compound of tobacco, which has, by itself has WEAK reinforcing properties. It is known that levels of the enzymes monoamine oxidase A (MAO-A) and MAO-B are reduced in the platelets and brains of smokers and that substances, other than nicotine, present in tobacco smoke have MAO-inhibitory activities. Here, we report that inhibition of MAO dramatically and specifically increases the motivation to self-administer nicotine in rats”
Link:
https://www.jneurosci.org/content/25/38/8593

“Several studies have documented a strong association between smoking and depression. Because cigarette smoke has been reported to inhibit monoamine oxidase (MAO) A in vitroand in animals and because MAO A inhibitors are effective antidepressants, we tested the hypothesis that MAO A would be reduced in the brain of cigarette smokers”
Link:
https://www.pnas.org/doi/abs/10.1073/pnas.93.24.14065

Effects of Monoamine Oxidase Inhibition on the Reinforcing Properties of Low-Dose Nicotine”
Link: Effects of Monoamine Oxidase Inhibition on the Reinforcing Properties of Low-Dose Nicotine | Neuropsychopharmacology


There is a hypothesis that substances present in, or derived from, tobacco smoke inhibit monoamine oxidase (MAO) in the brains of smokers, reducing the degradation of catecholamine neurotransmitters involved in central reward pathways and acting synergistically with nicotine to increase its addictive effects.
Link:
https://academic.oup.com/ntr/article-abstract/18/5/509/2511632?redirectedFrom=fulltext

“Interestingly, cigarette smoking produces inhibition of brain MAO activity in humans. Since monoamines are involved in the reinforcing and rewarding effects of tobacco smoking, MAO inhibitors have been proposed as a treatment for tobacco dependence

in vitro studies have identified several components, namely the alkaloids harman (a specific competitive MAO-A inhibitor; IC50=0.34 μM) and norharman (non-specific competitive MAO-A and B inhibitor, with IC50's of 6.5 and 4.7 μM respectively) as contributing to the inhibitory effects of tobacco smoke on MAO isoforms [21]. Besides harman alkaloids, other components of tobacco smoke may also inhibit MAO-A and –B [22, 23].
Since it has been observed that: 1) MAO inhibition leads to increases in synaptic monoamines which are also increased by nAChR activation; 2) cigarette smoke possesses components which inhibit MAO isoforms, we (and others) have reasoned that MAO inhibitors may be promising candidates for developing medications to aid smokers with tobacco cessation.“
link: Monoamine Oxidase Inhibition for Tobacco Pharmacotherapy


“Smoking inhibits the enzyme monoamine oxidase B (MAO–B), which is responsible for the catabolism of several brain neurotransmitters, including dopamine, serotonin and noradrenaline (Reference Haustein, Haffner and WoodcockHaustein et al, 2002). Smokers therefore have lower brain MAO–B levels than non-smokers, although levels return to normal on quitting (Reference Khalil, Steyn and CastagnoliKhalil et al, 2000). Inhibition of MAO–B causes dopamine levels to increase, thereby making smoking potentially rewarding. Long-term smokers have been found to have neurochemical abnormalities in the locus cerulus similar to those seen in animals treated with antidepressant drugs and opposite to those observed in people with major depression (Reference Klimek, Zhu and DilleyKlimek et al, 2001). Since MAO inhibitors are effective antidepressants, these findings suggest that smoking might have some antidepressant effects (Reference HughesHughes, 1999)”

I could go on and on with the links and sources, as the evidence is overwhelming. Does this mean everyone who smokes cigs becomes dependent on the MAO inhibition of cigarettes? No. Everyone’s brain chemistry is unique. For most simply replacing the nicotine is enough. However for some simply replacing the nicotine alone it is not enough (need the MAOIS and other alkaloids), and the links above explain why.
 
Last edited:

Izan

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Jul 1, 2012
8,869
15,701
Mallorca, Spain
Hi and welcome,
I have been vaping for 10 years and have just now reduced my nicotine level to 3mg/ml.
IMO, Stop pretending to want to quit and get some stronger nicotine liquid.
How long did you smoke and how many per day?
How many are you currently smoking per day?

Which device are you using and with which topper/coil/Ω/ Wattage?

I will leave the science to the boffins....

Cheers
I
 
  • Agree
Reactions: DavidOck

DavidOck

ECF Guru
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 3, 2013
21,239
178,485
Halfway to Paradise, WA
Unfortunately I cannot find any liquid that contains harman and norharman. I believe those are the only two things missing to make this nicotine juice work perfectly to get me fully off cigarettes.

My :2c:, I agree with @Izan , higher nic is called for.

I started at 18, and struggled for the first week of my switch. Got some 24, and that did the trick for me, haven't looked back. That was almost 10 years ago, and, yes, I have dropped my nic % down. To 18 :) (I tootle at about 8 1/2 watts.) I, probably like many, enjoy the hand to mouth process as much as the nic, so that works for me.

For me, 3 mg might as well be zero for all the effect it has. Yeah, I'd get anxious too!
 

UncLeJunkLe

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 29, 2010
10,627
2
28,689
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
nicotine alone (even 3mg per ml juice) gives me quite a bit of anxiety. I still vape anyways but hate the anxiety. Cigs don’t give me anxiety, in fact they often calm me while also being stimulating. Many times after a cigarette I have no anxiety left, so it reduces anxiety m. Yet vaping literally gives me anxiety. Also I noticed increased depression when trying vape only (due to lack of MAOIs and other tobacco alkaloids)

Like everything else in life, vaping isn't for everybody. People smoke for different reasons and vaping doesn't satisfy some people.

I personally don't want a lot of stuff in my juice, and certainly not MAOIs, synthetic or natural lol. If you need MAOIs when not smoking because you get depressed if you don't smoke, you may be better off seeking a professional who will prescribe them to you for oral consumption, rather than vaping them. Or you may want to try forums where people experiment with different supplements to alleviate depression and try those supplements...orally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DavidOck

Rossum

Eleutheromaniac
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2013
16,081
105,232
SE PA
Guys, there really are things in tobacco that are psychoactive besides just nicotine. Nicotine is what you miss first and foremost; I suspect it has the shortest half-life in the body. Nicotine alone is an adequate substitute for tobacco for some people, but by no means everyone.

Personally, I had a hard time with cravings even at 18 or 24 mg of nicotine, but WTA liquid helped a lot with that early on. To this day, I'll still use a drop or two here and there, and the difference is quite noticeable compared to straight nic that I use 99% of the time.
 

Rossum

Eleutheromaniac
Supporting Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Dec 14, 2013
16,081
105,232
SE PA
you may be better off seeking a professional who will prescribe them to you for oral consumption, rather than vaping them.
Bah. For things like this, "professionals" are just wealth extractors. I'd go buy some snus before I went that route.
 

Aerodan

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Aug 12, 2020
297
696
AZ
This is an interesting discussion OP, and it's easy to dismiss your experience with nicotine and anxiety vs. natural tobacco. But I'll add my unscientific and totally anecdotal experience.

Vaping nicotine makes my heart rate rise and does, indeed, increase my anxiety. Smoking loose leaf tobacco doesn't in the same way, nor does pipe tobacco.

Here's the thing: when I've tried any of the marijuana vape isolates vs. loose leaf, the effects are too powerful for me. No matter how it's mixed, I get the "up"'of a sativa and none of the relaxation. Interesting.

I have a working theory that isolate/extracted base chemicals are missing important terpenes that science has not perfected in replicating. I'm testing:

1_ Microdosing freebase nic in my own DIY mixes. Instead of 6-12mg, I use 1mg and vape more often during the day. So far, this has helped. It's still not like real tobacco, but it's better. 6-12mg of co2 or similar extracted nic is just pure blood pressure raising and not enjoyable for me.

2_ Labs have been looking at what gets lost in the extraction process of loose leaf tobacco. I was hopeful that they'd hone in on formulas that can replicate the full natural effects of loose leaf - but the more I read the more I realize how complicated it is.

Nature has been perfecting terpene chemical compositions for a very long time... humans have just started.

Anyway - please take no conclusions from my observations, since they're just observations and as a practitioner of scientific method, there's already too much pseudo science floating about.

...but maybe this can tip you to trying something different... microdosing for one, or simply changing your nic dose a little at a time to find the sweet spot.

AD
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread