I never smoked menthol but I had to start vaping menthol looking for that big throat hit. Now I like it! I still haven't found the perfect juice, but Strictly E Juice menthol 24mg is keeping the wolves away for now.
It's strange, but my first order from them was better than my second order. I guess no two batches of e-juice will ever be exactly the same.
The Atomic Cinnicide didn't work for me. Way too sweet. Unless you can handle the flavor of cinnamon candy, and I mean ALL DAY, I'd go the menthol route if I were you.
Everybody says that adding pure grain alcohol will add to the throat hit, but I haven't tried that yet. Being a recovering alcoholic, I probably won't try that.
I'm still looking for the right juice and I've tried a lot of them.
Ed.