Cookie Question - Mmmmmm nom nom nom

Status
Not open for further replies.

KnotGillty

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 26, 2012
352
297
Sacramento CA
What is your favorite cookie flavor? In looking at reviews, along with Brandon's 2011 top seller list, the three cookie flavors that I seem to hear the most about are:
  • Sugar Cookie
  • Snickerdoodle
  • Peanut Butter Cookie
Tell me which one you have tried or have the strongest attraction for? And if you've tried them all, which one hits your taste buds the best.

Thanks


PS: I haven't tried any cookie flavors yet, but I do have an order of Peanut Butter Cookie on the way . . .
 

CayCay

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2011
1,625
1,874
Austin TX
I have not tried peanut butter cookie yet but I plan to along with gingerbread cookies.

Snickerdoodle was my first love. That was the juice that kept me off cigs. Been almost 6 months and I ALWAYS have snickerdoodle with me, I'm actually vaping it right now. It's a dry bakery cinnamon with a sugary cookie... simply divine. WINNER!

Sugar cookie is another juice I can't live without. After it steeped about a week it became my favorite juice. Warm and sugary (but not too sweet) and I'm still amazed at how Ms T got the flavor of a cookie spot on. WINNER!
 
Last edited:

KnotGillty

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 26, 2012
352
297
Sacramento CA
Snickerdoodle was my first love. That was the juice that kept me off cigs. Been almost 6 months and I ALWAYS have snickerdoodle with me, I'm actually vaping it right now. It's a dry bakery cinnamon with a sugary cookie... simply divine. WINNER!

Sugar cookie is another juice I can't live without. After it steeped about a week it became my favorite juice. Warm and sugary (but not too sweet) and I'm still amazed at how Ms T got the flavor of a cookie spot on. WINNER!
So can the Sugar Cookie be described as a Snickerdoodle without the cinnamon?
 

Str8V8ping

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 10, 2011
3,944
2,077
NYC
Why do you gotta make me choose . I vaped over 400ml of snickerdoodle before i found Sugar cookie but i will admit that Sugar cookie i like a little better then snickerdoodle even

Sugar cookle imo is the greatest ejuice iv ever had by far and iv tried over 150 different ejuices from more then 20-25 vendors even the most popular juice like boba,BH,house,MT etc
Snickerdoodle is right there with Sugar cookie
Peanut butter cookies is also very good however its not in my favs because its a little overwhelming to vape all day everyday.

I wouldnt say sugar cookie is snickerdoodle without the cinnamon.Sugar cookie is really completly different. Sugar cookies a sweet but mellow tasting vanilla cookieish juice while snickerdoodle doesnt have one flavor note the same as sugar cookie. Snickerdoodle is a rich pungent cinnamon cookie flavor bursting with various flavor notes and a amazing sweetness and a nice strong baked taste. The only think id say they have in common is that they are both amazing and bot better then any ejuice ever made.

Gingerbread cookies is also a awesome cookie juice and that one has some similar taste properties of snickerdoodle.Gingerbread id say is exactly snickerdoodle without the cinnamon and a bit more gingerbread cookie taste. Quickly became my third fav cookie from mst.Cay you will love the gB cookie. If you like snickerdoodle you will for sure like GB
 

CayCay

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Oct 21, 2011
1,625
1,874
Austin TX
Gingerbread id say is exactly snickerdoodle without the cinnamon and a bit more gingerbread cookie taste. Quickly became my third fav cookie from mst.Cay you will love the gB cookie. If you like snickerdoodle you will for sure like GB

you have been keeping this from me!!! how long has this been your little secret??!
 

ITPython

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2012
334
288
Central Coast, CA
I just popped in some sugar cookie into a fresh carto, and WOW! This flavor is amazing! I wasn't too thrilled with strawberry shortcake or grape-a-licious as my previous cartos were adding some kind of burnt funk the flavor, so I took another risk on another fresh carto, and this one works exactly like it should without biasing the flavor!

And oh my gosh, I think I am on love! On inhale the warm sweet vapor oozes over your tongue and is CLEARLY present (unlike most other sweet vapes I have tried where really aren't sweet at all in inhale) but don't get me wrong, it isn't overwhelmingly sweet.

On exhale is a perfectly replicated fresh baked sugar cookie taste, almost as if I just took a bite into a fresh homemade sugar cookie only minuets out of the oven that is still warm and soft! It is absolutely astounding how accurate this tastes to a real sugar cookie! The flavor is really full and in your face (in a good way of course), something I have not yet experienced with other juices (even House Blend, which is fuller than anything else I have tried previously, but doesn't hold a candle to sugar cookie).


Well done Ms. T! If I still like this flavor after polishing off the 6ml sample, I am going right for the 30ml one ASAP! :thumbs:
 

Str8V8ping

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 10, 2011
3,944
2,077
NYC
Sugar cookie just get better and better the more you vape it. Its crazy.Your decription is the same thing i say . Its super sweet but not overwhelming at all somehow. Its not often you will see super sweet and mellow in the same sentence but that exactly what it is. Mst struck gold with the combination of flavor in this one. I also agree that i like house and BH but they truely have nothing on sugar cookie well except for TH but im not a fan of redculous TH. A mild but there for sure TH is what i like and sugar cookie is perfectly that.Also instead of a TH of harshness its a TH of flavor.
 

ITPython

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jan 24, 2012
334
288
Central Coast, CA
Exactly, TH IMO with ecigs is mostly just annoying, not sure why a harsh feeling in the throat is a good thing, I never got that with analogs. A good ecig TH to me means I simply feel feel the vapor being inhaled either from warmth or thickness of the vapor, but it doesn't have to be harsh or annoying to do that. With an analog if I really took a deep hit and got major TH, it actually meant something and I would get something out of it, TH (the harsh kind) with ecigs is pointless, as it doesn't tell you whether or not you are getting more nic or not as I could vape the same nic mg content with no TH whatsoever and still get the exact same level. Sugar cookie and the TH it gives performs very well for me, although the true test of harsh TH or not is when I vape it in the morning after I haven't had a puff in a long while.

But at any rate, I'm still vaping the sugar cookie and I am still loving every second of it! No harshness, no weird under/overtone flavors, just pure and full sugar cookie flavor. Even the vapor production is well above average.

Not sure if this could qualify as a ADV or not due to the sweetness, but I will find out shortly.
 

Str8V8ping

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Sep 10, 2011
3,944
2,077
NYC
exactly the type of th i look for is mainly being able to feel the lots of vapor going down my throat . Juices like BH are just harsh in TH which is not appealing to me.My favorite thing about sugar cookie is that its really sweet and rich but at the same time not overwhelming and i can vape it all day everyday.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread