EX Menthol Smokers.............

Status
Not open for further replies.

DTL33

Full Member
Aug 10, 2014
10
7
South Georgia
I need help, I need an ejuice tha is "like" my PalMals..............or even Salem Slim Lights, I smoked these for years and I think I need to keep a flavor *close* to this for my "with my morning coffee and after meals" . Can anyone suggest a flavor? I smoked Salem for YEARS until the price drove me to Pall Malls and I "made" myself go to the Pall Malls. I have found a flavor for "almost" a daily vape, but I need one for the major times, "coffee & meals". Can anyone suggest?
Thanks for any help!
 

Explicit

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Jan 2, 2010
83
24
Toronto Canada
I'm not sure if I can help. I vape Arctic Wolf from Vapor God. It makes Mt. Baker's Extreme Ice taste weak.

Ill have to try this. I thought Extreme Ice was pretty....well....extreme. Love me some good menthol. To the OP if I were you I would stay away from generic menthol flavors you find at B&Ms. I have had nothing but dissatisfaction with them so far.
 

Johnnie Price

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Nov 18, 2012
2,037
971
Waldorf, MD
Ill have to try this. I thought Extreme Ice was pretty....well....extreme. Love me some good menthol. To the OP if I were you I would stay away from generic menthol flavors you find at B&Ms. I have had nothing but dissatisfaction with them so far.

Just my opinion anyway. The prices are comparable with Mt. Baker as well. A 50 ml bottle is about $20 after shipping is factored in. I don't know of any coupon codes though.
 

Baditude

ECF Guru
ECF Veteran
Apr 8, 2012
30,394
73,076
71
Ridgeway, Ohio
Ice Menthol from Volt (Smokeless Image), Smooththol from NiQuid, Hybrid from Evo are what I use.

I have also made my own DIY menthol flavor using NiQuid's Added Burst, a no-nicotine menthol concentrate which I add to some flavorless pg/vg nicotine e-liquid. Only add a little bit at a time until you find what you like; you can always add more to suit your taste.
 
Last edited:

Mrdaputer

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Apr 28, 2014
1,209
663
MN
I need help, I need an ejuice tha is "like" my PalMals..............or even Salem Slim Lights, I smoked these for years and I think I need to keep a flavor *close* to this for my "with my morning coffee and after meals" . Can anyone suggest a flavor? I smoked Salem for YEARS until the price drove me to Pall Malls and I "made" myself go to the Pall Malls. I have found a flavor for "almost" a daily vape, but I need one for the major times, "coffee & meals". Can anyone suggest?
Thanks for any help!

I was a menthol smoker for many many years I tried a ton of different brands high end to house blends. To me none was like smoking a real menthol cig. I made my own just menthol and a few drops of koolada it helped. I finally went with apple pie and fruit as not to go back to smoking. Good luck in your search if you don't find a good menthol try something else.
 

Novena

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 10, 2014
131
713
Jacksonville, NC, USA
I was a Camel menthol smoker myself; did Newports for awhile as well. Not sure what the comparison would be to Salem or PalMal. I haven't tried a ton of menthol juices yet; all of the ones I've tried have been the Smooth Vapes brand from Carolina E-Cigs. Hubby likes their SV Menthol; I'm quite partial to their Smooth Ice. They have another, I think it was New Harbor, that was EXACTLY like a Newport.
 

Kenna

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 14, 2014
7,367
121,493
Texas, USA
Hj! I'm new to vaping, but am loving it! I was a dedicated menthol smoker for 40 years, & I figured out fast that finding a satisfying menthol taste was going to take some looking. I found what I needed with the Nicquid Added Burst Menthol. It is 0 nic, straight menthol that you use add a drop or 2 to any juice. It literally only takes a few drops to send the flavor through the back of your throat. It is the answer I was looking for, & I love it!. I add it to any flavor I choose to change it to a menthol flavor, & to flavors that claim to be menthol but are, sadly, lacking. Perfect fix! I got mine at Alt Smoke. You can only buy one bottle at a time, I think it's a 15ml bottle, which means I'll have a order more often than I would like since I like to share good things. So many are looking for a menthol answer & I just keep spreading the word. Wish I could get it in a larger size. HTH!
 

Kenna

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 14, 2014
7,367
121,493
Texas, USA
Hi! I'm new to vaping, but am loving it! I was a dedicated menthol smoker for 40 years, & I figured out fast that finding a satisfying menthol taste was going to take some looking. I found what I needed with the Nicquid Added Burst Menthol. It is 0 nic, straight menthol that you use add a drop or 2 to any juice. It literally only takes a few drops to send the flavor through the back of your throat. It is the answer I was looking for, & I love it!. I add it to any flavor I choose to change it to a menthol flavor, & to flavors that claim to be menthol but are, sadly, lacking. Perfect fix! I got mine at Alt Smoke. You can only buy one bottle at a time, I think it's a 15ml bottle, which means I'll have a order more often than I would like since I like to share good things. So many are looking for a menthol answer & I just keep spreading the word. Wish I could get it in a larger size. HTH!
 

xxxSapphir3xxx

Full Member
Aug 15, 2014
61
109
Michigan
I need help, I need an ejuice tha is "like" my PalMals..............or even Salem Slim Lights, I smoked these for years and I think I need to keep a flavor *close* to this for my "with my morning coffee and after meals" . Can anyone suggest a flavor? I smoked Salem for YEARS until the price drove me to Pall Malls and I "made" myself go to the Pall Malls. I have found a flavor for "almost" a daily vape, but I need one for the major times, "coffee & meals". Can anyone suggest?
Thanks for any help!

I'm a former Newport smoker, Nhale and titan vapors Nuport flavors are what we're suggested to me. I'm placing an order for both soon. I've tried 2 local liquids and one from vapor4life and I haven't been impressed with any.

What's come really close so far for me is an Ry4 tobacco that I added menthol to. It's a little too sweet but I think it comes pretty close as far as flavor goes. Most of the others I've tried tasted to much like mint.
 

Nick N

Ultra Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Jun 8, 2014
1,026
1,542
Columbus, Ohio
Ice Menthol from Volt (Smokeless Image), Smooththol from NiQuid, Hybrid from Evo are what I use.
Wife still smokes "Good Stuff" Menthol tobacco in Premier menthol tubes (RYO) and she likes Volt Ice Menthol. She is pretty picky too.

Arctic Wolf is good to add a cold Menthol kick, but straight is killer! One drop in a dripper is pretty intense.
 

Adrian Ludvik

Senior Member
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Aug 14, 2014
95
45
Ocala, Florida, United States
I smoked menthols for years as well. For a while I searched for that menthol tobacco flavor. Long story short, I went on mt baker vapor and made a custom mix that was half menthol and half tobacco flavor with the max nicotine. Worst idea ever. After about a month of vaping fruity flavors I realized that whenever I had a cig I hated the taste.

I just found it best to have about 5 flavors and rotate. Eventually you wont miss the taste of smokes. I've only purchase ejuice from mt baker vapor for some reason, Hawk sauce, thug juice, and jungle juice all have good fruity flavors with a bit of menthol to them. A buddy of mine enjoys himself a combo of hawk sauce and extreme ice.
 

Lovemychow

Full Member
Jul 28, 2014
37
22
West Virginia
I smoked menthol for years and started vaping blue ice. It was the strongest menthol I could find but it made my mouth very sore. It wasn't long until I started trying the other flavors and ended up with my favorite apple pie lol.....so strange. I wish I had stuck with the menthol because it's really hard to put down the good tasting juice!!:)
 

TheChromeKamuro

Senior Member
Verified Member
Jul 14, 2014
275
239
Sturgeon, MO USA
Card-carrying Salem/Kool/More Menthol/Pall Mall Menthol smoker right here. I could have quit smoking years ago if the powers that be would quit producing menthol cigarettes. :)

I've never found anything to compare taste-wise with any menthol cig, but I have found some exceptional menthol vapes. The most recent of which is Wintermint from ITCvapes.com. I got 50/50 6mg, and it's become my ADV. Lovely, cool throat hit, and several different types of mint including Wintergreen that I don't normally like because it reminds me too much of Pepto. :p

I highly recommend it and all of their products...it's not often that you don't have to steep first to really bring out the flavor. Best of luck with your search!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread