Fiction problem -- what to teach slaves?

Status
Not open for further replies.

FantWriter

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 11, 2010
601
5,429
Kentucky
(Sorry this is so long, but it's the minimum you'll have to know to form relevant opinions, and I don't want to get into the: "that's a good idea, but it won't apply here because . . . " loop which helps no one and always comes across as ungrateful or argumentative.)

I'm working on a spec-fic novel. I'm blocked because I don't know some things which aren't important to the story, per se, but they'd be important to the characters. The absence of insight into a portion of their daily activities has created a wall around them at a time when I have to be especially close.

Premise:
The protagonist is a time-traveler. Needing a safe place for R&R between trips, he set up housekeeping in early 15th Century England.

This entails buying some 8-year-old girls to serve as maids. Reasons:
1) The natives then/there were particularly suspicious of people who lived alone. They would never believe even a minor noble would cook his own meals or wash his own clothes. Having locals living in his house will prevent a lot of distrust.
2) Adult servants would spy on him.
3) His claiming he has to train them to do things the right way feeds into the 'foreign nobles are very fussy' mentality.
4) If they were any older, they'd be harder to coerce into washing their hands, brushing their teeth, and taking baths regularly (it was an era when even the king had serious b.o., rotten teeth, and fleas).
5) He's sort of a nice guy, and while he can't save the whole world, he can take a few destined for drudge slavery and give them an easier life as housekeepers.
6) It's nice to have a maid! :)

He splits their days between education and housework because:
A) He buys/trains far more than are necessary to keep the house spotless (Reason #5, above).
B) There might come a day when he doesn't come back from one of his trips, and he wants them prepared to go out into the world as something other than household drudges.
C) The lessons are open-house, and those natives who come to spy on him might learn something that would make them better people and, in turn, that world a better place to live.

The major problem I'm having is what to teach them.

Reading and writing are marginally acceptable in that setting (teaching slaves to read was considered eccentric, but it wasn't against the law).
Literature is iffy because of the lack of novels written for 15th Century slaves.
Arithmetic is fine, but anything beyond simple trig would be wasted.
I believe Philosophy would be best worked into other material rather than presented as a stand-alone course.

The local priest will teach them those parts of the Bible which the Church considered suitable for laymen to know.
History is taboo. He's supposedly from a land beyond China, so he shouldn't know anything that's happened in that part of the world since the flood. Locally available books were rare and treasured -- nobody would loan one to somebody who'd let slaves handle it.

Economics would be meaningless.
Botany is about the only science which wouldn't tread dangerously close to heresy. Chemistry and astronomy are completely taboo because of their association with the black arts. (The Church is very tolerant because of his generous donations, but there are limits on what they'll allow.)
Medicine is a minefield.
Art, music, etc. are difficult because he isn't particularly gifted, and the instruments/materials of the time were very limiting.

What would be useful for them (and the world of that time) to learn?
 
Last edited:

Iffy

Vaping Master
ECF Veteran
Verified Member
Feb 3, 2011
9,626
79,411
Florida Suncoast
Literature is iffy because of the lack of novels written for 15th Century slaves.

What would be useful for them (and the world of that time) to learn?

Well, since you drug me into this scenario
finger-point.gif
; math (including trig pertinent to navigation), nutrition and herbal medicine, if he was knowledgeable in the latter two.
 

FantWriter

Super Member
ECF Veteran
Dec 11, 2010
601
5,429
Kentucky
(I'm sure you're a very literate person, but I didn't mean to mention you by name.)
Thanks for replying!

Math -- I've included arithmetic, up to basic trig. Anything much beyond finding the length of the sides of a triangle wouldn't have practical use. Navigation? That need is more than a hundred years away.

Nutrition -- other than balanced meals, what is meaningful in everyday lives? Vitamin and mineral contents sound much like a religion or an alchemical formula.

Herbal medicine -- Herbs are mostly the dominion of cooks and witches.
He's pushing the germ theory of disease as a theological issue (God created plants and animals of all sizes; Satan corrupted some to do evil and cause suffering) and cleanliness as disease prevention (God used a flood to cleanse the Earth of evil).
I'm afraid that anything bordering on cures would be seen as witchcraft or heresy.

They're in their third year. All classes but arithmetic are over because the subjects have been covered as thoroughly as necessary or practical (cooking, health, reading, writing, botany, etc.). What now?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread