Being a ex menthol light smoker myself, I wish I had better news....but menthol
flavor juices out there (I have about 10 that I have tried from 5 vendors) are not going to be
quite the same as the cigs.
The taste factor on ALL juices is very much a individual preference that
you personally
will have to decide.
Just because I like it, does not mean you will.
You will need to order several small bottles from a few different vendors and give them a try.
What I am now using for my menthol satisfaction is a cinnamon/menthol combo
juice (Pure Smokers
Fire and Ice) and I combine that with a tobacco flavor
juice and it gives me a close duplication.
Most menthols I tried were very minty and had very little to no tabacco flavor to them.
So that is my overview for menthol, but probably others will jump in and give you some thoughts as
well.
I hope that it all works for you and let us know if we can help in any other way!