Thank you Iken, I do appreciate your helping ...
and Im still thinking what you could have won.... hmmm...
will this do?
and Im still thinking what you could have won.... hmmm...
will this do?
Had to go get gg from the post office!
- Thread starter jonw
- Start date
- th_trl_thread_readers 0
- Status
Got to admit that I'm getting worried & hope Imeo is OK. He managed to post on one thread this afternoon but not answer Tim's post. I hope he hasn't had a relapse due to his operation 
Rejoice, Jonw has a transformer. He receive it a little earlier that yours because jonw will make many reviews about it. We had many conversations in the past for many things, so I send it to him 3-4 days before yours.
He knows what he is talking about
I'm anxious to see an in depth review of the Transformer. When will this be available?
I read the anonymous reveiw - nicely done.
It's my understanding that JonW was sent the Transformer early in order to provide an in depth review. I was just curious when it might be available.
It's my understanding that JonW was sent the Transformer early in order to provide an in depth review. I was just curious when it might be available.
- Suzi
Moog
I know the one you refer to Moog, posted by Imeo...
Im afraid I dont take any notice at all of anonymous reviews - A review can only be taken seriously if the person doing it signs it...
Sorry but thats my opinion..
I agree with you christena. I just post it because I receive it by mail. Sorry, if I recieve again reviews that they demand to be anonumous I will not post them. I would like to say who he is but I cant sorry.
Shame you say that since I know the person that spent the time writing it for you Imeo. So a review form you lot are the only valid reviews, I did expect more....
absolutely not Moog, thats the whole point... only reviews where the validity can be checked are of worth in my opinion..
The person didnt want his or her name mentioned, and thats a shame, but it was their choice.
If I read a review from someone I respected as knowing ecigs, and not necessarily a fanboy or girl, then that review would have more credibility to me than one written by me say for the JantyStick... as everyone knows I love Janty..
See what I mean?
That review that Imeo posted was excellent, but it wasnt signed, so how do I know Imeo didnt write it?? thats my point..
The person didnt want his or her name mentioned, and thats a shame, but it was their choice.
If I read a review from someone I respected as knowing ecigs, and not necessarily a fanboy or girl, then that review would have more credibility to me than one written by me say for the JantyStick... as everyone knows I love Janty..
See what I mean?
That review that Imeo posted was excellent, but it wasnt signed, so how do I know Imeo didnt write it?? thats my point..
Shame you say that since I know the person that spent the time writing it for you Imeo. So a review form you lot are the only valid reviews, I did expect more....
If you know the person moog then this review is real so now you just convinse Christena!!!
Thanks a lot, now I apreciate this review more than any other and I can speak for it freely.
Its a well written review, a very well written review, the man says everything that other people wants to know about Trans, it gives more than info to future byuers and it shows all GGs abilities.
Thanks a lot my friend, many people will understand many things about Trans after your exellent review and as moog said I want to thank you so much for the time and effort you spend for GG. I hope you enjoy your GG ritght now!
The fact that moog *says* he knows who wrote the review does nothing to validate it, IMO.
It's still an anonymous review, which carries no weight with me.
Now, if it's HIS review and he owns it, it's another matter. Has he gotten a Trans, too - before the others that won them in the contest?
Back to the question... when do we get to see this review from JonW? That was the purpose of him getting his early.
It's still an anonymous review, which carries no weight with me.
Now, if it's HIS review and he owns it, it's another matter. Has he gotten a Trans, too - before the others that won them in the contest?
Back to the question... when do we get to see this review from JonW? That was the purpose of him getting his early.
girls, moog is not my friend, that means he cant lie to this matter, so the review its true. Am I right?
But if you insist, no problem, I had forgot this review and I can do it again
But if you insist, no problem, I had forgot this review and I can do it again
No Imeo, we are not asking you to remove it, not at all.
We are simply responding to Moog saying that only a review made from a GG forum person is valid, or words to that affect...
We are pointing out that a signed review is the only review that is acceptable.. even if 10 people say they know who wrote it... as long as the reader doesnt know, then its not valid.
We are simply responding to Moog saying that only a review made from a GG forum person is valid, or words to that affect...
We are pointing out that a signed review is the only review that is acceptable.. even if 10 people say they know who wrote it... as long as the reader doesnt know, then its not valid.
Can I just add, Moog is a respected friend of mine, and if he said he knows the person who wrote that review, then I believe him.
However, this is simply a discussion over whether a review which is anonymous is acceptable to all.... its not specifically about that review Imeo..
However, this is simply a discussion over whether a review which is anonymous is acceptable to all.... its not specifically about that review Imeo..
girls, moog is not my friend, that means he cant lie to this matter, so the review its true. Am I right?
But if you insist, no problem, I had forgot this review and I can do it again
I'm not debating whether the review is real or not. I'm saying that it being anonymous carries no weight for me.
You're logic about whether or not moog is your friend being the determining factor as to him knowing this anonymous person or not doesn't make sense.
I'm not familiar with moog. I'm sure he's a stand up guy. I'm certainly not calling him a liar. I'm saying that his professing to know this anonymous person still doesn't lend to it's credibility, IMO.
Some people don't know you Judgemental so your review won't mean anything to them either. I do understand Christenas point though, sorry for posting on your forum someone asked about a review and I pointed them to one... I wish you would all stop being so bullish and overprotective....Sorry Imeo if I caused you problems with your friends...
I wish you would all stop being so bullish and overprotective....Sorry Imeo if I caused you problems with your friends...
how are we overprotective? simply said, I wouldnt trust a review that was not signed.. simple as that, so who am I over protective of?
Myself I would say....lol
As far as I understood it, we were having a discussion about reviews, nothing serious, nothing important, am I missing something?
Myself I would say....lol
As far as I understood it, we were having a discussion about reviews, nothing serious, nothing important, am I missing something?
- Status
Similar threads
