I enjoy the heck out of few of halo's juices for the mellow clean taste and awesome vapor they provide. Tribeca was a love at first
vape experience for me, and I continue to love it (after several 30ml bottles)...captain jack however, didn't agree with my taste buds at all.
I didn't pick up the rose petal or maraschino cherry taste you mentioned, but am
almost tempted to revisit it just to see if I can spot those flavors. What I did get was an extremely sharp, overpowering perfumey tobacco taste, sort of like dripping a strong men's cologne - with prominent tobacco/leather notes - into an atty and taking a puff...bleh. It's not my thing, but some hardcore tobacco lovers might enjoy this juice. After all, one vaper's poison is another's nectar, so to each his own.
Although CJ is not my thing, I love that halo continues to branch out with new juice flavors that they beta test on their customers. Gotta love them for that!